AITAH for marrying another man and not getting back with my children’s father?

Deciding to rebuild life after an abusive marriage takes immense courage, especially with children involved. Many divorced parents face guilt over moving forward, fearing it will hurt their kids or shatter family hopes.

A 39-year-old mother navigated this after ending a 14-year marriage marked by verbal abuse, neglect, addiction, and physical violence. Three years post-divorce, she found love with a kind widower and planned to remarry. Announcing the news sparked outrage from her teenage sons, who accused her of abandoning their father and destroying reconciliation dreams. Their reaction, fueled by manipulation, forced her to confront painful truths and seek professional help.

‘AITAH for marrying another man and not getting back with my children’s father?’

The story details the breakdown of her long marriage and the challenges of co-parenting.

I (39F) was married to my ex-husband 'Ex' (42M) for 14 years, we got divorced three years ago, he was getting increasingly verbally abusive, barely had any time for our...

On top of that, he developed an alcohol addiction. I filed for divorce when he hit me in a fit of rage. Our divorce was difficult since he refused to...

I didn't budge. We now have joint custody of our children (15M, 15M) and (9F). I had been seeing my now fiancé (44M) for a couple of years. He is...

I am absolutely in love with this man, and he makes me happy. I had even introduced him to my children. My fiancé was not pushy, he respected their boundaries,...

Last week, I broke the news to my children that I would be marrying again. Needless to say, they didn't take it well. My sons yelled at me that I...

That I moved on too quickly while their father is still inconsolable and grieving. My sons were polite, wonderful young men, and it was a shock to me that they...

My children said that they were waiting for their mom and dad to get back together but I ruined it all. That I was ditching them and their father, who...

They further said that while I replaced their dad with another man, their father did not replace me.

ADVERTISEMENT

I had already told Ex that he is free to date whoever he wants, provided she is a good lady to be around our children, it wasn't my fault that...

My children said they would absolutely not come to my wedding and would cut ties with me if I married another man.. This scared me. Even though I love my...

An update reveals manipulation and steps toward resolution.

ADVERTISEMENT

ETA: Well, I sat my boys down, and asked them why they thought I was coming back. They said dad told them that him and I have had such fights...

This did not sit well with me, and I contacted him, and he had the audacity to say, "Aren't you?". He went on about how my new 'toy' doesn't love...

He wouldn't shut up about how I replaced him, while he hasn't even been on a date. I then hung up on him.

ADVERTISEMENT

I am consulting my lawyer now, to look into the custody arrangements, and tell my children the truth. I am also gonna admit my children and I into family therapy....

The primary tension arises from parental alienation after domestic abuse. One parent rebuilds a healthy life, while the other fosters false reconciliation hopes in children, distorting reality and loyalty. This manipulates emotions, placing kids in conflicting roles.

Drivers include the mother’s pursuit of safety and happiness post-trauma, contrasted with the ex’s unresolved control and denial. Teens absorb idealized narratives, fueling anger toward change. Shielding details initially protected them but enabled misinformation to take root.

ADVERTISEMENT

Family therapist Dr. Amy Baker, expert on parental alienation, explains that “Children exposed to alienating behaviors often develop distorted views of the targeted parent, leading to resistance or rejection.” (Various publications) This matches the sons’ hostility, amplified by the father’s ongoing influence despite past violence.

Prioritize therapy with a domestic violence specialist for age-appropriate truth-sharing. Document alienation for potential custody review. Model healthy boundaries consistently. Reassure children of unchanging love while validating feelings, guiding them toward independent perspectives over time.

Let’s dive into the reactions from Reddit:

Online reactions overwhelmingly supported the mother, urging truth-telling and therapy while condemning the ex’s manipulation. Users emphasized protecting her happiness and addressing alienation.

ADVERTISEMENT

Strong calls emerged to reveal the full divorce reasons to the older children.

Bonnm42 − NTA but I think you need to tell your sons the truth behind your divorce. Your daughter may be a little young still, but your sons are not....

“In light of your recent ultimatum, I feel it necessary to tell you the truth behind your Father and I’s divorce. I wanted to shield you from the truth, but...

ADVERTISEMENT

Any time a man puts his hands on a woman, that should be the last time for that woman. It was for me. I would not subject myself to emotional...

I want my children to grow up and find healthy relationships that make them happy. My Fiancé has always treated me with respect and kindness. He makes me very happy....

I also understand this information is a lot to absorb. I think the best thing to do after this conversation is not to say anything right away. Let yourselves process...

ADVERTISEMENT

When you are ready to talk about it, I will be here. I love you and I hope this will make things clearer to you both. ” If you have...

Their first instinct will probably be to think you are lying. Although in all honesty, if your ex was abusive and an a__oholic, I’m surprised you let him see the...

Final-Success2523 − NTA but you need to tell your children the whole truth and tell them their father was a terrible husband who hit you that’s not something you can...

ADVERTISEMENT

millerlite585 − It's time to tell the kids the truth, that he hit you and a man can never hit a woman and then expect things to be good again....

Honestly, IMHO, a man who beats his wife should never have access to children, because he could never be capable of teaching then proper values.

ThaiVixen − NTA But you should talk to your kids as to why the divorce happened. They need to understand what happened, then hopefully they'll react differently.

ADVERTISEMENT

ImprovementMental646 − NTA - Your kids are now old enough to be told the truth. I would say your ex might be putting a narrative out there and distorting the...

He was abusive towards you, that's domestic violence and it usually escalates to much worse, it rarely is a 'last time i do it'. I would be honest with your...

Sure they were younger when it happened but they deserve the truth that mom didn't break the marriage to be with another man. If after hearing the truth they decide...

ADVERTISEMENT

Also if you are to tell them the full extent of the divorce please make sure they go to therapy or to see a shrink so they are supported and...

They also need to understand that life isn't a fairytale and mom and dad don't necessarily go back together like in the movies, that sometimes some things are unreconcilable.

Don't sacrifice your own happiness for your son's choice, just be truthful to them so they know the reasons and let them decide what to do with the information.

ADVERTISEMENT

lovinglifeatmyage − You need to tell your sons the brutal truth why you and your ex parted. It sounds as though he’s been indulging in some parental alienation over the...

Many highlighted parental alienation and recommended therapy or legal steps.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − Your kids need therapy. Sounds like Dad is in their ear telling them they could have a happy family if you hadn't moved on.

Hold off on the wedding until the therapist helps you explain why you left your ex. Glad you're happy in a safe and loving relationship, 14 years is a long...

AllRumoursNoGlamour − NTA - You are not choosing your fiancé over your children, you are choosing him over their manipulative father. Your children are in a disadvantage here.

ADVERTISEMENT

They only see their poor grieving father without knowing the whole truth. It may even be too late, because he has had enough time to thoroughly manipulate your children.

On the other hand, I would try to make them understand that physical and psychological abuse are boundaries that must never be overstepped.

And there no way back from that. Tell them the truth. They are old enough. This can be a good teaching moment for your kids with regard to their own...

ADVERTISEMENT

Equal-Brilliant2640 − You need to put your marriage on hold. You ex had clearly been poisoning your children towards your fiance Therapy now. They need to understand the real reason...

That ex was an a__oholic, mentally and verbally abusive and became physical and that why you divorced not because “mommy and daddy changed” or whatever you told them.

I would also speak with your divorce lawyer and going back to court about custody/visitation there is clearly parental alienation going on here and it needs to be stopped It...

ADVERTISEMENT

but the younger one maybe saved NTA, but DO NOT get married until things have been sorted out with your kids

ceokc13 − So congratulations on your engagement! As long as he treats you and your kids well I don’t see an issue with you continuing to have a relationship with...

You are choosing yourself over your ex (as you should) and have been since you left. Let’s say you break up with your fiancé for your kids… your kids are...

Definitely get your kids in therapy because your ex has been feeding them a bunch of his narrative, you may want to tell them the truth and why you left...

throwaway_ArBe − NTA. Stuff like this is why I always disagree with "taking the high road" and not "s__t talking" (read: criticising) the other parent in cases of abuse. Im...

but you've allowed an abuser to be their only source of information about the divorce. Of course they are acting like this. Your ex, like every other abusive ex, is...

For yours and your children's safety this needs to be addressed. Unfortunately at this point they are unlikely to listen to you. A therapist who specialises in family mediation and...

For anyone else going through a situation like this, while its rarely best to share gory details, children are never too young to know when a divorce has happened because...

Edit: also not to be alarmist, but just to prepare you for what a therapist might say. Kids can pick up an abusers behaviour and values.

Your older boys talking the way they are at the age they are is very concerning, and a therapist may be concerned that they may become perpetrators if this is...

Lyzab77 − What I don't understand, it's how a judge has considered your ex had the right to have 50/50 custody BEFORE a bif therapy for his a__oholism and violence....

The problem, I understand, is that you want your children to be happy too. They need to see someone neutral to explain them that their parents divorced from each other,...

Someone who explain too to their father that he has no right to talk sh*t about you to your children. .. You ex is still toxic and needs to do...

A few focused on standing firm against manipulation.

ExternalRip6651 − INFO: Are any of the children aware of the full extent of the reasons why you divorced?

rendar1853 − NTA but your ex has been fueling the fire behind your back. Sorry but you should've been more honest with kids.

You need to sit them down now but you may find that the damage is done and they will NEVER accept another man in your life. You may need to...

[Reddit User] − You’re their mother. Do not let them bully you. Give them a chance to see reason and you, yourself, need to move in the direction of happiness...

That’s a certainty. Do not allow yourself to be bullied by your own progeny. That’s bananas.

This mother’s journey highlights the lasting impact of abuse and alienation on families. Choosing safety and happiness models strength for children, even amid resistance. Her proactive steps—truth, therapy, legal review—offer hope for healing fractured trust.

Would you delay a wedding to resolve family conflict, or proceed while addressing issues separately? How soon should parents share abuse details with teens after divorce?

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *