AITA for telling my mother that I wont miss her because she told me i wasnt her child?

A single heated outburst can fracture a mother-child bond in an instant. In an Asian household where education is paramount, a devoted mother who sacrificed everything for her child pushed her own dream of becoming a doctor onto them. When her child refused, a cruel remark slipped out, leaving deep emotional scars.

This story reveals how words can wound and how family expectations can strain even the strongest ties. Can love mend the damage? Let’s explore a young person’s struggle against their mother’s ambitions and the lively reactions from an online community.

‘AITA for telling my mother that I wont miss her because she told me i wasnt her child?’

It all started with OP acknowledging their parents’ sacrifices, especially their mother’s devotion:

Before I begin I would like to put out a disclaimer. Both my parents sacrificed A LOT to bring me up. My mom especially threw away a lot of luxuries...

My mother wants me to be a doctor. It was her childhood dream that she couldn't fulfil so she thought she could fulfil it through me. I have nothing against...

As college applications loomed, the mother pressed again, escalating the conflict:

She has been quiet for a while but now its time for applying to college and she asked me to apply for med school. Again I repeated what I always...

Then she proceeded to tell me that i was dead to her and she only had one child (my sister). Something inside me knows that she didnt mean it and...

I looked at other colleges (one's that I love) and applied to it. My neighbour asked me in front of my mother if I would miss my family when i...

The mother’s tears and family division followed:

My mother is now crying and telling me that I was ungrateful for saying i wouldnt miss them after everything they did for me. I asked her why i would...

ADVERTISEMENT

She told me she didnt mean it and that she only said it in the heat of the moment. I told her these are things thats going to hurt me...

Now half of my family is calling me TA. The other half her and a small percentage says NAH as we both had valid reasons to be upset. I think...

OP clarified the cultural context and the neighbor’s misunderstanding:

ADVERTISEMENT

EDIT :A lot of people in the comments think I shamed my family in front of my neighbour. I would like to clear the fact that my neighbour thought I...

My mother knows that too because she never brought up this point. Also, I dont know if this will change your judgement but I come from an Asian family that...

EDIT: Both my mom and I apologised to each other. I told her i was sorry for hurting her and tried to explain what my ambitions were.

ADVERTISEMENT

She heard it all and told me aa long as I think its good for me i had her blessings. She Also apologised like all Asian mothers; cooking me my...

This clash between OP and their mother mirrors a common tension in Asian families, where lofty career expectations can strain relationships. The mother’s unfulfilled dream of becoming a doctor led her to pressure OP, culminating in the crushing remark that OP was “dead to her.” Though likely said in frustration, those words cut deeply, undermining OP’s sense of belonging.

Dr. John Gottman explains, “Harsh words in moments of anger can leave lasting scars, especially when they challenge a child’s place in the family” (The Relationship Cure, 2001). OP’s sharp retort—saying they wouldn’t miss their mother—was a raw expression of that hurt. While understandable, airing it publicly in front of a neighbor likely deepened the rift.

ADVERTISEMENT

Culturally, Asian families often see children fulfilling parental dreams as a form of respect. Yet, today’s youth increasingly value personal choice. OP’s decision to pursue their own path was valid, but a gentler approach might have spared further pain, given the cultural emphasis on family harmony.

Moving forward, OP should keep sharing their dreams openly while honoring their mother’s sacrifices. For the mother, embracing OP’s choices is the truest way to show love. Their reconciliation, marked by a heartfelt meal, is a hopeful step, but ongoing communication is vital to rebuild trust.

See what others had to share with OP:

The online community buzzed with reactions, offering a wide range of takes on this family drama.

ADVERTISEMENT

Many users stood firmly behind OP, arguing the mother’s expectations were unfair:

geegeepark − NTA Parents should never use their children to fulfill they own dreams. Children have their own lives and dreams and are not simple extensions of parents. Hopefully you...

bluebell435 − NTA. Your mom doesn't have a valid reason to be hurt. She hurt you and she hurt herself. You are entitled to choose your own career. She should...

ADVERTISEMENT

Callipygianbunny − NTA. She is an adult that chose to have children. It is absurd for her to assume you would follow in HER dreams just because she didn’t fulfill...

Sure what you said was not very nice, but from what she said is the reason you felt that way. She is the mother, she shouldn’t be putting her stuff...

When you decide to have children they are always your children, no matter what decisions they make in life. She should be proud of you for continuing your education in...

ADVERTISEMENT

hiii_impakt − NTA. Why would you miss someone who told you you were dead to them? Simply providing for your child financially doesn't make you a good parent.

koopakup2 − NTA. She’s an adult. Saying something that harsh and unjustified “in the heat of the moment” has consequences. She’s just upset that she can’t get away with it...

Others connected deeply, sharing their own painful experiences:

ADVERTISEMENT

ToPregnant − NTA things like that hurt and you will carry that whit you the rest of your live. When I was 9 my father told me he never loved...

HunterRoze − NTA - I grew up with a mom that started telling me she regretted my birth and wished I had never been born starting when I was 5...

You have every right to feel the way you do. The rest of your family giving you a hard time never had their mom say they were not their child...

ADVERTISEMENT

You were NOT rude to your mom, you didn't disown her or try to force her to do anything - that was all her. OP I hope you show your...

If you are luck some day OP might want to overlook your comments - but don't bet on it. Almost 50 years later and I still remember all the times...

immadriftersbody − NTA one bit. When I was 18 I was with a guy and was starting to get serious (ended up breaking up a few weeks after this incident...

ADVERTISEMENT

I wasn't actively trying but said I wouldn't be too upset if it happened, my dad flew off the handle saying if I had babies with the guy I was...

Followed by him yelling at me that I was a disgrace, disappointment, the worst child ever. I cried for weeks following that. He eventually apologized and begged for our relationship...

I hate him. I hate he ever even had that thought of me, and it's DAMAGING. It's been 3 years since he said that s__t and I grey-rock him and...

ADVERTISEMENT

Pain-n-stryife − You not wanting to do what she wants isn't a valid reason to be upset first off. You don't get praises for being a responsible adult and raising...

Nowork_morestitching − NTA. She doesn’t get to say something that hurtful and not expect to get hurt in return.

ADVERTISEMENT

Some offered humor or deeper reflections to shed light on the issue:

NomadofExile − NTA. And I HATE the "heat of the moment" excuse like that's just supposed to make everything better. Yes you were hurting. Yes you said something to either...

Yes you wouldn't normally say that. No you don't get a pass. I'm a human being with feelings that don't get to be dismissed/ignored because you had an "episode".

ADVERTISEMENT

slytherinserpentine − Hahahaha my mom disowns me once a day. I studied what she wanted me to. I do what she tells me to. And if I do anything on...

im supposed to be grateful to her and cancel it the moment she wants me to. To hell with the reasons. It could be worse, OP. Emotional mothers tend to...

MsRenee2020 − Words have power. Especially coming from a parent. Your mother lived her life and made her choices. It’s now your time to make yours. NTA

ADVERTISEMENT

istoleurface1789 − NTA I can't see how this could be a one time incident as it is so callus, has she not done or said anything like this before? Even...

Imo I think what you said wasn't nice but is nothing compared to what she said and if that's the way you feel then you were just being honest.

Your mum can cry all she wants but how can she expect any different when she told you that you're dead to her? I hope that you can reconcile with...

ADVERTISEMENT

A few believed both sides shared fault, calling for mutual understanding:

lucia50457 − Mild ESH Because your mum said something really crappy and hurt you without considering your wishes. But it feels like you have a lot of respect for your...

Also sounds like you know she doesn't believe the crappy things she's said and was lashing out from a place of hurt yet you chose to say something hurtful back....

This story underscores the weight of words and the need for open communication in families. The mother’s push for her own dreams led to hurtful words, while OP’s response reflected deep pain.

Their reconciliation shows hope for mending ties, but it raises questions about balancing personal dreams with family expectations. What do you think of their approach? How would you navigate parental pressure versus your own goals?

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *