AITA for seeking My Daughter’s Perspective on Her Father’s Feelings about me?

What happens when you unintentionally place an emotional burden on your own child? A 37-year-old mother, grappling with the pain of her husband’s repeated infidelity, asked her 14-year-old daughter a tough question: does her father still love her?

This question sparked a conflict, as the daughter felt pressured and revealed she’s been forced to act like an adult for too long. The mother acknowledged her mistake but still felt hurt. Did she go too far? This story isn’t just about a family conflict—it raises questions about the boundaries between parents and children.

‘AITA for seeking My Daughter’s Perspective on Her Father’s Feelings about me?’

The story begins with a mother struggling with the pain of her husband’s multiple affairs.

my daughter (14F) and I (37F) have always had a close relationship. She was a daddy’s girl too, before she found out he cheated on me; she was actually the...

Anyways, the cycle continued; he would leave his phone open, and one of his mistresses texted. He would use tons of different socials to cheat on me with. And I...

I need help, and I'm not gonna let him get away with it that easy, but when they are old enough, I’m divorcing his ass. Anyways, recently it has been...

The conflict arose when the mother asked her daughter about her husband’s feelings.

Here is when I may have been the a__hole: I asked her if she thought he still loved me after everything. She told me she doesn’t want to say the...

But that didn’t satisfy me enough, and I told her she wouldn’t be in trouble if she would just answer the question. She said she doesn’t know. I asked her...

The daughter expressed frustration, prompting the mother to reflect on her actions.

She said she regrets even telling me anything and that she’s always been a parentified child who has to help me because even before we found out he cheated, I...

ADVERTISEMENT

And it truly hurt my feelings, and I am going to try and stop. She walked away and later told me she was sorry and didn’t mean it, but I’m...

And keep her out of my marital, issues. But I still don’t think I was as bad as she’s saying. It’s true that I may have done some of those...

The mother clarified that her daughter unintentionally discovered her father’s affairs.

ADVERTISEMENT

EDIT:he’s cheated on me numerous of times and my daughter and husbands phone are somehow synced so he can get her stuff sometimes and she gets his and this is...

And she also has come to hate him recently and engage in conversation so im not the only one

This story revolves around unintentionally placing an emotional burden on a child. The mother’s question about her husband’s feelings put her daughter in an unfair position. This reflects “parentification”—when children are forced to take on adult roles. Dr. Lisa Damour explains, “Children should not be responsible for managing their parents’ emotions.” — Lisa Damour (Psychologist), Under Pressure, 2019 .

ADVERTISEMENT

Pressing the daughter to answer after she refused shows a lack of sensitivity to her boundaries. This can harm the mother-daughter relationship and make the daughter feel trapped. On the other hand, the mother’s pain from betrayal makes her seeking comfort understandable, but misguided.

From a societal perspective, this story highlights a common issue: parents sometimes lean on children for emotional support, especially in strained marriages. This can rob children of a normal childhood and affect their mental health long-term.

The consequences of parentification can persist into adulthood, leaving children feeling overly responsible for family issues. The mother needs to seek support from professionals or friends instead of her daughter. Can the mother-daughter bond be repaired after this strain? This question prompts reflection on parental responsibilities in protecting children from adult burdens.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here’s what Redditors had to say:

The online community largely criticized the mother, emphasizing that she was wrong to involve her daughter in marital issues.

Many agreed the mother was wrong to pressure her daughter with an inappropriate question.

Appropriate-Value54 − YTA. She’s absolutely right with what she said and sounds like an insightful kid. I’m sure you’re struggling and I’m sorry that your husband is putting you in...

ADVERTISEMENT

You also have to already know you that were wrong for pushing her after she said she was uncomfortable answering. What does that teach her about her boundaries and autonomy?...

Also, apologize to her and get yourself a therapist too. Even start journaling in times that you find yourself wanting to vent or ruminate about your husband. Your teenage daughter...

anglflw − YTA Your daughter, who is only 14 years old, is not your girlfriend. You don't bring her into your romantic relationships. That is for you and your husband.

ADVERTISEMENT

You are actually probably worse than she's saying, because I bet you have asked her to care for her younger siblings, as well as had inappropriate conversations with her about...

StripedBadger − Yes. YTA Your daughter is not your therapist. She is not the best friend you get coffee with. She is your daughter. It is not fair or right...

Some urged the mother to protect her daughter instead of burdening her.

ADVERTISEMENT

rae_of_sunshinee − YTA. You both need to get therapists and you need to stop treating her like one. I don't understand how your first instinct isn't to protect her from...

Own_Lack_4526 − YTA. That is a horrible thing to ask a 14-year-old about her own father.

[Reddit User] − YTA - Don't, I repeat. .. Do not put your daughter in the middle and ask her questions like this. She's your daughter, but she's also his...

ADVERTISEMENT

The community stressed that the mother is forcing her daughter into an adult role, harming her.

anothertypicalcmmnt − YTA You're treating your daughter like a fellow adult friend under the excuse of you two being "close". It sounds like she feels like you treat her as...

Besides, the girl is 14 years old, wtf does she know about what love between two adults in a complicated marriage looks like? ? If you need someone to talk...

ADVERTISEMENT

imyourkidnotyourmom − YTA. This isn’t your friend, your mother, or your sister. This is your CHILD. She is 14. She needs to be learning how to have relationships FROM you,...

KaijuAlert − YTA - You are choosing to stay in a bad marriage and trying to force your daughter into taking the mental burden. Read between the lines - she...

Some advised the mother to apologize and seek professional help.

ADVERTISEMENT

-Maris- − She walked away and later told me she was sorry and didn’t mean it, but I’m still hurt. Of course YTA. Easy call here, this is parenting 101....

The fact that she even felt the need to aplogize tells me just how much your roles are unfairly reversed - that you "still feel hurt" tells me how self...

You're allowed to have a lot of emotions about the termination of your marriage, but your big hurt feelings are not her job to manage. You've made her your defacto...

ADVERTISEMENT

Logical_Read9153 − DO NOT PUT YOUR CHILD IN THE MIDDLE OF YOUR MARRIAGE PROBLEMS! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! " I asked her if she thought he still loved me after everything.

She told me she doesn’t want to say the wrong thing and that we will be separated soon anyway, and it doesn’t matter. But that didn’t satisfy me enough, and...

ADVERTISEMENT

THIS IS DISGUSTING. THERE IS NO JUSTIFIABLE REASON FOR YOU TO HAVE ASKED YOUR DAUGHTER THIS. YTA X INFINITY

The community agreed that the mother was wrong to involve her daughter in marital issues. They emphasized that she needs to protect her daughter and seek professional support instead of relying on a 14-year-old.

This story underscores the importance of shielding children from adult emotional burdens. Parents must seek appropriate support to avoid harming their children.

ADVERTISEMENT

What would you do if you found yourself leaning on your child for comfort in a tough situation? How can healthy boundaries be established in a family?

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *