AITA for not turning off my cat’s TV show to avoid an argument with my ex?

A quiet afternoon turned into a fiery argument over… a TV show for a cat! A social media user shared a story about refusing to turn off their cat’s favorite Netflix program when their ex came over to discuss their rocky relationship. He got upset, claiming she was being disrespectful, but she stood her ground: this is her and her cat’s home, and the cat comes first.

Beyond the quirky premise, this tale reveals deeper layers of past struggles and a relationship steeped in drama. Was prioritizing a pampered feline really the issue here? Let’s dive into the details, from the heated clash to the lively reactions from the online community!

‘AITA for not turning off my cat’s TV show to avoid an argument with my ex?’

The story kicks off with a messy relationship and a cat who rules the roost.

My ex and I were best friends in high school then had a short relationship in 2016 that ended with him basically ghosting me. We reconnected in 2020 and it...

 

Anyway, I live on my own with my cat who gets treated like royalty. My ex has expressed several times his displeasure of my house "being a shrine to my...

He has expressed before that he is not jealous of the cat, just annoyed that I give him so much attention and will choose the cat first. Meh, sounds like...

A simple Netflix switch for the cat ignited a full-blown argument!

A few weeks ago, we needed to talk some things out over our relationship, so he came over to talk and I had a movie on.

After about half an hour I changed the movie over to my cat's favourite show on Netflix, a preschool show about baby animals narrated by children. This would keep my...

Anyway, my ex got mad. He didn't ask, he told me to turn the TV off. I said no it's for [cat], and he got mad and told me to...

ADVERTISEMENT

He stood up and paused, then got his finger out and berated me. Saying that I always need to have the last word, always need to have my way, that...

that he's a guest and has made a request and I'm not accommodating him, do I not realise how rude I am being? I scoffed and said this is my...

He told me he never wanted to see me again, slammed the door and got maybe ten minutes away before messaging me never to contact him again, which I have...

ADVERTISEMENT

After the clash, the poster reflects on their past and makes a bold choice.

People think I should have avoided an argument and turned off my cat's show but no, it's my house and I applied for this house specifically for my cat, he's...

Also ETA: As mentioned in the comments, my cat's brother that I adopted with him as a kitten was tragically lost when we were struggling with FV and housing insecurity.

ADVERTISEMENT

This is another reason why I baby my cat, because he had a tough time losing his brother and we both struggled through a period of emergency housing, homelessness and...

Also ETA: I have found this shared to Facebook groups and will not be commenting anymore. I am deleting the photo of my cat for our privacy.

ETA 3.0: Ex showed up to my house unannounced yesterday, I was on the phone. He brought a packet of cat treats for my cat. When I wouldn't get off...

ADVERTISEMENT

Later, I called to apologise and he yelled at me on the phone for not terminating the phone call so we could "hang out". I told him I would not...

It's been over a year of trying to break away from this toxicity and after reading some of these responses I'm finally going to just break all contact and block....

A cat, a TV show, and an argument—what seems like a quirky spat reveals deeper issues about personal boundaries and control in relationships.

ADVERTISEMENT

The core of the poster’s issue isn’t just about keeping the TV on for their cat; it’s about a clash over control. The ex’s frustration with the cat’s priority and his demand to turn off the TV suggest he wanted to impose his will in her personal space. This points to a relationship lacking mutual respect, where the ex disregards the poster’s boundaries.

On a broader level, the poster’s devotion to her cat might seem unusual to some, but it’s tied to past struggles. The ex’s failure to acknowledge this, instead making controlling demands like turning off the TV or interrupting a phone call, highlights his lack of empathy.

As psychologist John Gottman notes, “Respecting your partner’s boundaries is the foundation of a healthy relationship” (The Seven Principles for Making Marriage Work). The ex’s behavior suggests emotional control, which can erode trust.

ADVERTISEMENT

Advice:

  1. Stick to the decision to cut contact with the ex to protect your mental well-being and your cat’s peaceful environment.
  2. Consider therapy to process past traumas and strengthen personal boundaries.
  3. Connect with fellow pet lovers to build supportive, positive relationships.

Here’s What People Had To Say To OP:

Social media buzzed with support for the woman’s stand, alongside some thoughts on her cat obsession.

These users backed her right to rule her home and pamper her cat.

ADVERTISEMENT

Spotzie27 − NTA Let Mittens (or whatever his name is) watch his stories!

InsaneMisha77 − NTA Red Flags are waving everywhere. Your ex is jealous of your cat, period. Your cat likes to watch TV?

Great... keep your cat entertained instead of causing some havoc in the bathroom by rolling the toilet paper or chewing the plants or stealing food off of the table. Whatever...

ADVERTISEMENT

fiftycamelsworth − NTA. Your house, your rules. You're a cat lover. If he can't even let you care for an animal you love in your own home, then he isn't...

readshannontierney − NTA. You're way better off without the ghosty screamer with the accusation finger. Live your best life with your cat, and don't look back.

NobodysBabyDaddy − NTA. If someone comes into my home, and tries to tell me what to do, I tell them where to go. Especially if it involves my pet. But...

ADVERTISEMENT

These comments highlight why her cat means so much.

guttertrashfish − I've just come out of an appointment and can't believe that some people are so judgemental over my treatment of my cat. I've been homeless and estranged from...

I am doing nothing wrong for spoiling a living thing who kept me from k**ling myself during my darkest days. He deserves more than he has, he's the best.

ADVERTISEMENT

And I don't have kids, I pay my bills, I help everyone else when I can and don't ask for squat. So I'm allowed to spoil my cat with a...

[Reddit User] − NTA My cat loves nature bird shows. It will chirp and chirp at the computer when they are on.

Fuzzypants19 − Omg I love this "I applied for this house specifically for my cat, he's on the lease, it's HIS house." I can see the lease now "lease holders...

ADVERTISEMENT

Some users supported her but raised concerns about balance.

0biterdicta − Not going to arm chair diagnosis, but the babying your cat and being in an on and off relationship with a toxic guy suggests to me speaking with...

ADVERTISEMENT

9for9 − I think your cat is excessively spoiled if you can't have a conversation with a guest without having to have the tv on for your cat for fear...

You're allowed to have an excessively spoiled cat as long as it's not hurting anyone. Your ex' sounds like a drama queen and a control freak probably best he's out...

[Reddit User] − The... cat is on the lease? Is the landlord aware he's renting to an actual not-human being? Wow. Okay, so, the guy is a d**k and you're...

ADVERTISEMENT

That being said... You might find yourself having difficulty with human relationships. I think a lot of people would be annoyed/concerned/etc. to share you with a cat you treat with...

These comments urged her to ditch the ex for good.

whyagaypotato − NTA but you ARE being s**tty towards yourself. Do you honestly believe you deserve to go through all this drama, stress, and bullying from your ex? Just block...

ADVERTISEMENT

Queen_Sized_Beauty − Dude. Just block him.

[Reddit User] − NTA but you really need to pay the cat tax.

Most users sided with the woman, slamming her ex’s controlling behavior and cheering her devotion to her cat. Some noted that her cat-centric lifestyle might complicate future relationships, but agreed she was right to stand her ground.

ADVERTISEMENT

This story shows that loving a pet can be a lifeline, especially after tough times, but it can spark misunderstandings if not explained. The ex’s controlling antics prove he’s not worth keeping around. Your home is your castle—especially when it’s your cat’s castle too!How would you handle a guest demanding you change your pet’s routine in your own home? How do you balance pet love with human relationships? Share your thoughts below!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *