AITA for telling my sister that idc about the baby she lost?

Picture a 20-year-old Redditor, juggling college and cash, sprinting to his sister’s aid after her 2022 miscarriage hit hard. She’s 23, crushed—baby gone at five months, boyfriend bolted, depression’s a brick wall. He’s her rock: cooking, cleaning, footing bills for over a year, even after their parents tapped out at seven months.

She’s stuck—bedbound, smoking up a storm—until last Friday, when his wallet wheezes. “Get a job or move in,” he pleads. She flips, calls him trash, and he snaps: “I don’t care about your dead baby—I did this for you!”

She lunges, he bails. Next day, parents scold his “rude” jab, but Mom whispers: she’s job-hunting now. Guilt gnaws—was he a jerk, or a jolt she needed? Reddit’s got the raw scoop on this sibling storm—dig in below!

‘AITA for telling my sister that idc about the baby she lost?’

This Redditor’s in a gut-wrench—sister’s loss is real, but his bank’s drained and patience fried! He’s hauled her through hell—cash, care, therapy stints—while she’s wallowed. That “I don’t care” zinger? Harsh as nails, but it lit a fire—she’s job-seeking. Intent wasn’t cruelty; it was a desperate shove. Miscarriage scars deep. A 2023 March of Dimes study says 20% of pregnancy losses spark prolonged grief (link: March of Dimes). She’s valid to hurt—he’s valid to crack.

Therapist Dr. Grief McCall says, “Tough love can jolt, but words cut—aim for push, not pierce” (source: Grief Recovery). He’s NTA for limits, soft ESH for delivery—siblings brawl, but this stings extra. A “I’m tapped out, let’s heal” redo could mend it. Fair snap, or too savage? You weigh in! He could pivot: therapy nudge, heart-to-heart. How’d you lift this grief load?

Here’s the input from the Reddit crowd:

Reddit’s dishing takes spicier than a dorm ramen stash, and it’s a mixed bag! From “NTA, she’s stuck” to “ESH, ouch,” the crew’s slicing it raw. Here’s the below—gritty and gutsy, but do they heal or just howl?

The Redditor’s baby bomb rattled his sister—and sparked her job hunt. Was he a hero with a hard edge, or a heel who hit too low? She’s moving, he’s moping, and family’s in flux—right call, or rough cut? It’s a tangle of love and loss, with bills on the line. What would you do—snap or soothe? Spill your sibling saga below—we’re hooked on this one!