AITA for telling my wife she should’ve written it (my kid doing summer band) on the calendar?

Picture a bustling suburban kitchen, where a wall calendar hangs like a silent referee amid family chaos. A father, fresh from a long workday, steps into a simmering tension: his wife forgot to drive their teenage son to summer band practice. The oversight feels like a dropped note in their family symphony, with the 17-year-old son quietly waiting to see if Mom would remember. The dad, caught between work and church duties, points to the blank calendar, igniting a small but fiery debate.

This relatable Reddit tale pulls us into the heart of family dynamics, where unspoken expectations and mental loads clash. The original poster (OP) wonders if he’s wrong for calling out his wife’s lapse, while their son’s subtle test adds a layer of intrigue. Readers can’t help but wonder: who’s really responsible for keeping the family rhythm in tune?

‘AITA for telling my wife she should’ve written it (my kid doing summer band) on the calendar?’

My kid (17M) just graduated high school and will be a freshman at Southern California in the fall. He doesn’t drive right now but will be getting his license in July. The community we live in is doing a summer band that meets on Tuesdays in June from 7:00-8:30PM and he joined it.

At our church I have been assigned chair of the Associate Pastor Nominating Commitee that will meet every Tuesday at 5:30PM from now on so now my wife is the one that has to drive him to summer band.

Well, when he first started, I told her before I left for work the day he first started to write it on the calendar in the kitchen while she was nearby so we wouldn’t forget. Today, I got home at about 6:50 and noticed she had just had gotten dinner ready. I asked her if she forgot about the summer band and she said yes.

I then asked her if she had written it on the calendar and she said she forgot to do it. I then asked my son if he forgot too but he said no and he was waiting to see if she remembered. He said she should’ve wrote it down on the calendar,

and that he shouldn’t have to remind her every Tuesday and I told her that. She asked me why I couldn’t have just taken him today but I reminded her that I work and I’m now the chair of the Associate Pastor Nominating Committee. AITA for saying this?

This family’s calendar conundrum is a classic case of miscommunication dressed up as a blame game. The OP’s frustration with his wife highlights a deeper issue: the uneven distribution of mental load in households. Let’s unpack this with a touch of sarcasm—because who doesn’t love a family expecting one person to be the human Google Calendar?

The OP’s wife is juggling dinner and daily life, yet the responsibility for their son’s band practice lands squarely on her. Meanwhile, the 17-year-old, soon off to college, plays a passive game of “will she remember?” instead of grabbing a pen. According to a 2019 study from the American Sociological Association, women in heterosexual relationships often bear 70% of the mental load—planning, remembering, and organizing family tasks (American Sociological Association). This dynamic seems to be at play here, with the wife left as the default scheduler.

Dr. John Gottman, a renowned relationship expert, notes, “Equity in household responsibilities fosters mutual respect and reduces resentment” (Gottman Institute). In this case, the OP’s quickness to blame his wife sidesteps his own role in the oversight. Both he and his son could’ve jotted down the band practice, yet they leaned on her to carry the mental weight. This points to a broader issue: the expectation that women instinctively manage family logistics, often without acknowledgment.

The solution? Shared responsibility. The OP could initiate a family meeting to divide tasks clearly—perhaps a rotating calendar duty. The son, nearly an adult, needs to step up, too. Encouraging him to manage his own schedule builds independence, vital for college life.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here’s the input from the Reddit crowd:

The Reddit crew didn’t hold back, serving up a spicy mix of wit and wisdom. They dove into the OP’s story with raised eyebrows and sharp takes, questioning why a grown teen and his dad left the wife to play schedule-keeper. Here’s the unfiltered scoop from the crowd:

[Reddit User] − Info:. - why isn’t your seventeen year old son taking more charge of his life? - Why is he still relying on your wife to write down his events on the calendar like he’s a five year old little boy?. - Are his hands broken?

CheerilyTerrified − Info: Why didn't you add it to the calendar?! And why is your son setting weird tests for his mum instead of just picking up a pen.. Edited to add - YTA

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − info: why didn’t you write it on the calendar?

[Reddit User] − Your son is 17 and headed to college...now is a good time to act like the young adult he is and voice that he needs to be somewhere he needs to take responsibility for his actions. You two can write on a calendar just as well as she can. Yes you both are the AH

[Reddit User] − YTA.. he said no and he was waiting to see if she remembered. Well, your son's learned a valuable lesson: don't wait for other people to remember your important commitments for you,

ADVERTISEMENT

let alone sit around and wait for them to notice you need something from them instead of speaking up. You really shouldn't be undermining that. (Although frankly, the fact he didn't make an issue out of it suggests he doesn't want to go that badly anyway, so...)

IAmAllOfTheSith − I then asked my son if he forgot too but he said no and he was waiting to see if she remembered.. And you're enabling this? YTA, be a parent first and help your wife.

Graves_Digger − YTA. Your son is plenty old enough to be writing his own commitments on the calendar and sticking to them. He's going to have a hard time in the real world if he can't even do that for himself. Next you're going to tell us he can't cook or do his own laundry.

ADVERTISEMENT

facinationstreet − YTA and your son is TA. Why is it your wife's job/responsibility to keep all of this straight? If your son wants to be in band, it is 100% his responsibility to make sure he gets to band. Not to sit around 'testing' his mother, who I can assure you, does not GAF if he goes to band or not. WTF is wrong with you?

Spotzie27 − I’m now the chair of the Associate Pastor Nominating Committee.. Is that supposed to mean something?

SwiftChallengerNomad − YTA. Either you or your son could've written it down. It's unfair to expect your wife to remember and manage everything when there's a calendar right there that you could have written on to make sure things happened. Go and read up on mental load and how rembering everything that needs to be done almost always falls on women in relationships.

ADVERTISEMENT

These Redditors tore into the OP and his son, cheering for the wife’s side or shaking their heads at the teen’s test. Some called it a lesson in responsibility; others saw it as a family fumble. But do these hot takes capture the full picture, or are they just stoking the drama?

This tale of a missed band practice reveals how quickly family harmony can hit a sour note when expectations aren’t aligned. The OP’s blame, the son’s test, and the wife’s oversight highlight a universal truth: communication is the glue that keeps households humming. By sharing the mental load and fostering independence, this family could find a smoother rhythm. What would you do if you were caught in this calendar clash? Share your thoughts and experiences below!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *