AITA for telling my ex-girlfriend I won’t help her until we do a DNA test?

Four months ago, I (25M) and Emma (23F) ended our two-year relationship with a friendly goodbye, promising to stay in touch. Then, two weeks back, she called, voice shaking: she’s three months pregnant and says it’s mine. She wants us back together, raising a family. I’m stunned—we used protection, haven’t been together since the split—but the timing fits. I asked for a DNA test before committing, and now she’s furious, rallying friends to call me a jerk for doubting her. Did I mess up?

‘AITA for telling my ex-girlfriend I won’t help her until we do a DNA test?’

Breakups leave echoes, and this one’s ringing loud. Emma’s hurt, clinging to a story I can’t fully buy—not without proof. Dr. Shirley Glass, a relationships sage, once wrote, “Trust is a bridge rebuilt with facts, not feelings” (from Not Just Friends). I’m not calling her a liar; I’m just lost in the fog of “what if.” We used protection—religiously—so her certainty feels like a leap. Meanwhile, she’s pushing for a redo of us, and I’m wondering if this is less about a baby and more about a second chance she wants me to take blind.

She sees betrayal in my doubt; I see caution in a life-altering claim. The clash? Her heart’s screaming “believe me,” while my head’s whispering “be sure.” Stats say 1 in 25 paternity claims turn out wrong (American Pregnancy Association, 2023), and that’s enough to pause.

Her rallying the troops—friends, family—feels like a play to corner me, and it’s working. Some get my side; others see a cold skeptic. Solution? A prenatal DNA test—safe, pricey (up to $2,000), but a lifeline to clarity. I’d pay, I’d support emotionally, but I won’t dive in blind. Readers, is this paranoia or prudence?

Here’s the comments of Reddit users:

Reddit’s crowd weighed in with a mix of fire and reason. Most lean toward “not the asshole,” arguing a DNA test is a fair ask when an ex drops a bombshell like this—especially post-breakup with no recent intimacy. They see Emma’s pushback and guilt trips as red flags, hinting she might be leveraging emotion over evidence. A few sympathize with her hurt but still back the test, saying trust isn’t the issue—certainty is. Overall, they urge standing firm: if it’s yours, step up; if not, don’t get trapped.

So, am I the ass in this drama? Emma’s tears tug hard, but doubt’s a stubborn knot I can’t untie without a test. She’s got our breakup wounds wide open, and I’m stuck—wanting to help, but not ready to bet my life on faith alone. Friends are picking sides, and I’m the guy who won’t budge. Maybe I’m too clinical, or maybe I’m just scared of being played. If your ex hit you with this curveball, would you trust or test? Drop your take—let’s sift through this mess together.

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *