AITA For Vetoing My Wife’s Plan To Name Our Son Lannister, Breaking Our Naming Deal?

Jonathan Hours
Comments 0 Comments

A name can shape a child’s destiny, but what happens when it’s inspired by a family of fictional villains? In a cozy living room, a soon-to-be father wrestles with a peculiar dilemma: his wife’s insistence on naming their son Lannister, straight from the scheming, wine-sipping clan of Game of Thrones. The tension is palpable, as their once-lighthearted naming pact now teeters on the edge of a marital showdown.

This Reddit tale has sparked a frenzy of opinions, blending humor with heartfelt debate. Readers are hooked, wondering if the husband’s veto is justified or if he’s betraying their deal. With the baby’s arrival looming, the couple’s clash over Lannister’s legacy invites us to ponder: how far should love stretch for a name?

‘AITA For Vetoing My Wife’s Plan To Name Our Son Lannister, Breaking Our Naming Deal?’

When we got married, my wife and I made a deal that she gets to name our male children while I get to name the females. Our first child is a girl and I named her. Our second child is a boy, so my wife should be the one to name him. However, when she told me that she wanted to name our son Lannister after her favorite Game of Thrones family, I put my foot down.

I'd have no problem if she wanted to name our dog Lannister, but this is our son. I asked her if she really wanted him to be named after a family of villains, but she just reminded me of our deal. She said she liked the Lannisters and it was her turn to name our child, so he would be named Lannister. We've had this conversation countless times and she refuses to budge.

The birth will be a C-section and I'm seriously considering filling in the paper work myself while she's still out. I know this might sound unfair to my wife given our deal, but wouldn't it be more unfair to my son if he was named after a family of power grabbing incestuous wine guzzling villains?

Edit: She does not want a middle name. She wants his name to be just Lannister Ourlastname. Edit 2: The Lannister motto is 'Hear me roar'. The line 'A Lannister always pays his debts' is just a common saying.. Edit 3: No, our daughter's name is not Daenerys. It's Margaery.. I kid, it's Margaret. Edit 4: To those who are saying they have to know if my son will be named Lannister. He is due to be born in September. I will try to post an update then.

Naming a child can feel like scripting their life’s first chapter. This couple’s clash over “Lannister” reveals deeper tensions about trust and shared decisions. According to Dr. Laura Markham, a parenting expert, “Names carry emotional weight, and both parents need to feel heard to avoid resentment” (Peaceful Parenting). Here, the husband’s veto stems from fear of bullying, while the wife clings to their pact, perhaps feeling dismissed.

The wife’s choice of Lannister, tied to a fictional family known for cunning and controversy, raises eyebrows. Names influence social perception; a 2018 study by the University of Michigan found unique names can invite scrutiny, though they also foster individuality. The husband’s concern about bullying isn’t baseless, but his plan to secretly fill out the birth certificate risks trust.

Dr. Markham advises, “Compromise builds stronger partnerships.” Suggesting alternatives like Lance or Landon could honor the wife’s taste while sidestepping stigma. This saga reflects a broader issue: parenting demands teamwork. Rigid deals, like their naming pact, can crumble under real-world stakes.

For solutions, the couple should revisit their agreement with open hearts. A neutral mediator, like a counselor, could help. Exploring names with similar sounds or meanings—like Lionel, meaning “lion,” echoing the Lannister motto—might bridge their gap.

Here’s the comments of Reddit users:

Reddit’s hive mind didn’t hold back on this naming drama. Here’s a roundup of the spiciest takes, served with a side of wit:

ADVERTISEMENT

flyinpanda - NTA, the way I've always heard, each parent gets unlimited vetoes on names. She can still pick the name, but not this one. It should be that way for you picking female names.. YWBTA if you fill out the paperwork and pick the name yourself. That's way over the line.

[Reddit User] - NTA.. 1. Some second names arent meant to be first names.. 2. It’s a stupid f**king name as a first name.. Have you considered asking her if she would have lanister as a middle name?. For example the boys name could be Jamie Lanister Jelly3. Don’t think that would be so bad.

ADVERTISEMENT

sonic_banana - NTA. That child would be bullied mercilessly. I say you get veto power, but she still gets to come up with names.

MizBird - NTA on the name, I think both partners should be able to veto with good justification. 100% YWBTA if pick your son's name and put it on the birth certificate while your wife is in *surgery.* That's despicable. (EDIT: This not even legal in the U.S. anyway As far as I know, the mother completes and signs it.---nope it looks like it may be legal to do.

ADVERTISEMENT

Seems to vary from state to state..... I just think that's super gross to even suggest doing that. Dude, the mother of your child is having her f**king abdomen cut open for your kid, not running out to the grocery store. Have some respect.) My suggestion would be to find a similar sounding name (Lance, Landon, Lannis?, Lancelot) or just forget this idea of each person picking and try to pick it together.

EDIT: I agree, Lancelot is *crazy*. I figured I had to throw in a crazy one since OP's wife likes crazy names. Lancelot is a knight who has an affair with Guinevere and kills King Arthur(? or inadvertently leads to him dying or near dying in a battle. So many different versions). Probably one of the inspirations for Jamie Lannister. Lesser of evils in my book, and could be easily shortened to Lance down the road 😉.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] - ESH: You f**ked up with that deal. You can't name the kid without your wife's knowledge; that road leads to divorce. You are parents and grown ups. Find an agreement that adults do not children.

Konouchii - NTA My mother always had the rule you could try, OP. 'If you're unsure of a child's name, picture yourself at a park full of kids and calling out to them. If it sounds stupid, change the name.' Ask her to try visualizing yelling out 'Lannister' and see if she backs down. Jaime is a better boys name and subtle so less likely he's going to be asked if he fucks his older sister when he grows up.. Edited because I forgot to cast my NTA vote.

Daedalusrift - Don't fill out the paperwork yourself; that's just sneaky and will really destroy what should be a happy occasion.. You're NTA for not wanting to name your child that. I'd be trying to veto it too. However I'm wondering if the real issue here is that your wife doesn't feel like you respect her decisions (and by extension, her)?

ADVERTISEMENT

You talk about 'putting your foot down' and planning on filling out the form before she can (with what name? Something you've decided on?). You guys had an agreement and you're the one breaking it. Even though you think you're 'right', I'd recommend aknowledging that, apologising for it and asking her if there's something else you can do to make it up to her?.

The more you push, the more she's going to dig her heels in. Back off a bit. (Edit: I'm not a GOT fan but the motto of the Lannisters is 'a Lannister always keeps his word' - that might say something about what's important to your wife. How good are you at keeping yours?. Also, maybe have a look at names that have similar meanings). Edit: thank you to the people* who gave this comment silver!

nottoday1217 - NTA. The 'deal' isn't an end all be all. You need to tell her to knock that s**t off. 'I get to name our son after a family of incestuous murderers because we made a deal' nah dude.

ADVERTISEMENT

CashieBashie - NTA to veto, the a**hole if you forcefully do it.. Just start calling the baby Bannister when you reference him.

Voxit - NTA - 'Lannister' is gonna end up as one of the names on the list on /r/askreddit when people ask what's the most ridiculous name people have heard.

These Reddit gems range from practical to snarky, but do they capture the full picture? Naming a kid isn’t just about vetoes—it’s about building a family’s future.

ADVERTISEMENT

This tale of Lannister leaves us chuckling yet pondering: names are more than labels; they’re legacies. The husband’s instinct to protect his son clashes with the wife’s creative freedom, making their story a relatable tug-of-war. Should he break their deal, or is compromise the true hero here? Share your thoughts below—what would you do if your partner picked a name straight from Westeros?

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *