AITA for not adjusting my daily run/walk schedule to accommodate for my MIL showing up unexpectedly, and telling her she should call ahead?

Venus Hours
Comments 0 Comments

The dawn was crisp, the world still cloaked in pre-sunrise hush, when the OP laced up their running shoes for their sacred 6 AM routine—a lifeline for their mental health. But the morning’s calm shattered when their mother-in-law (MIL), fresh from an unannounced visit, insisted they skip their run for her breakfast plans. The air grew thick with tension as the OP held firm, sparking a clash that sent the MIL packing in tears.

For the OP, those early miles are more than exercise—they’re a therapist-endorsed anchor in a stormy sea of mental health struggles. The MIL’s surprise arrival, paired with her pushy demands, felt like an invasion of a carefully guarded routine. This story dives into the delicate dance of family boundaries, personal well-being, and the chaos of uninvited guests.

‘AITA for not adjusting my daily run/walk schedule to accommodate for my MIL showing up unexpectedly, and telling her she should call ahead?’

I struggle with mental health issues and likes to keep a specific routine. One of the things I do is that every single morning at 6:00 AM, I get out of bed and either go for a walk or a run. The only exception is bad weather, and if that happens, I have a workout I’ll do instead. The walk/run is between 5-8 miles.

I’ve done this every single day with very minimal exceptions for the past several years. This was started as a recommendation from my therapist and it’s something we both agree is a huge help for me. I’m unable to take medications to manage my issues, so I have to do whatever else I can. I take it as seriously as I would taking meds.

My MIL is typically nice and easy to get along with, but clingier than I can handle. If she had it her way, he would call every single week, go visit her every other week, etc. It’s annoying but whatever. Well last week she decided to just show up in the afternoon to drag us out for a quick hike.

We went along with it, but because of the long drive back, she demanded to stay overnight. We let it slide. But when I got up to go at 6AM for my walk she tried to stop me and told me that she was making breakfast and that I needed to wait. I told her no, I’m heading out, I’ll be back in an hour or so.

She kept pushing, saying she was a guest and was here to visit us, so I should just spend time with her. I said that I will when I get back. We went back and forth on this a little bit until I finally snapped and said “Listen, this is what happens when you don’t call ahead to make plans to visit us.

I’m not going to change up my life because you couldn’t be bothered to call ahead.” I left for my run and felt better. My husband was annoyed at me when I got back and said that his mom was in tears and took off back home and that I should have just stuck around.

I said that I know how she operates, and that yeah it starts out as breakfast, but then she’ll want to sit around and talk and talk and talk, then she’ll want to go stroll around the shops, then probably lunch and more talking. MIL vagueposted about me on FB, saying that she wishes young people understood how important family is, and all this flowery Mom/Grandma FB posting crap.

It seems my SIL (husband’s sister) knew about what happened, because she commented with a corny sad face and said “They’ll understand some day, Mom.” AITA, really? Should I have just blown my whole routine out the water and messed up my entire day/weekend because she couldn’t be bothered to call ahead?

ADVERTISEMENT

EDIT: Holy s**t, some of you are seriously weird with the projection and making s**t up based on three of my comments. 'OP doesn't have ANY friends and EVERYONE HATES HER' 'OP is RUINING her husband's relationship with his mom he's being ABUSED and CONTROLLED.' 'OP is OBSESSED with running because she has to STICK to a ROUTINE.' All because I don't like idle chit chat with my in-laws, like... come on.

Unannounced family visits can feel like a warm gesture or a boundary breach, depending on the context. The OP’s clash with their MIL over a morning run highlights the tension between personal needs and family expectations. The OP’s routine, a therapist-recommended lifeline for mental health, is non-negotiable, akin to medication. The MIL’s push to prioritize her visit over this routine, while rooted in a desire for connection, ignored the OP’s well-being.

ADVERTISEMENT

This reflects a broader issue: balancing family closeness with personal boundaries. A 2022 survey by the American Psychological Association found 68% of adults report family dynamics as a significant stressor, often due to uncommunicated expectations. The MIL’s unannounced visit and emotional reaction suggest a need for clearer boundaries, while the OP’s sharp response reflects frustration from repeated oversteps.

Dr. John Gottman, a renowned relationship expert, notes, “Respecting individual needs within family systems requires open communication and mutual empathy.” The OP could calmly explain their routine’s importance, while the MIL should respect their space.

ADVERTISEMENT

Check out how the community responded:

The Reddit crew didn’t hold back, dishing out opinions with the zest of a morning coffee run. From fiery defenses to practical advice, here’s what they said about this boundary battle.

cheesencarbs − NTA I hate when people pull the “I’m a guest” BS. That doesn’t mean you get to upend my entire life. It would have been different even if she talked about it the night before.

ADVERTISEMENT

stannenb − NTA. If it were *really* about family, as your MIL said in her Facebook post, your needs would be as important as hers. Clearly, they’re not, so it’s really about your MIL’s n**cissism.

SiameseCats3 − NTA. You were gonna be gone for about an hour from 6-7am! The fact that she burst into tears and fled the house because you said no to breakfast at that hour is insane. Was your husband even up? What if y’all didn’t wake up at that time?

Why can’t she hold off her breakfast? She kept pushing you when it should have been a simple “I am going for a run for about an hour” and she said “oh well I was going to make breakfast now and I cannot wait an hour” and you say “I’m sorry but I’d really appreciate it if you just wait an hour for breakfast

ADVERTISEMENT

because I need this run to better function for the day ahead and during this day we can be together” and then you leave because she understands. Your response was very understandable because I do not know why she was pushing this. It’s not as if she had already made breakfast and it was going to get cold.

soyboydom − NTA for this particular situation, but I do think your definition of “c**ngy” is too harsh. I try to call my parents at least once a week, and if I lived in the same town as them I would certainly try to see them once or twice a month (or more) without issue.

They aren’t c**ngy, but we love each other and enjoy seeing and talking to each other on a regular basis. I don’t think those are unreasonable standards for a parent to hope for if they have a good relationship with their kid. If she lives far away I could see not wanting to visit so frequently

ADVERTISEMENT

but I still don’t think a phone call once a week counts as c**ngy. That being said, showing up unannounced and expecting you to change your plans for her with zero warning is still super rude. You’re not the AH for being upset as she was way out of line,

but you probably could have gotten a better outcome if instead of snapping you had more calmly expressed that your routine is really important to you and if she would like you to reschedule your plans to spend time with her, she will need to *ask* (not tell) you ahead of time.

ETA: You should also have a longer conversation with your husband about this. Your needs are important, and he needs to have your back when his mother is not respecting them. It’s not okay for her to show up without warning and get mad when you don’t want to change the plans you already had in place, and it is your husband’s job to set that boundary with her.

ADVERTISEMENT

cautiouslizard − Nta lol she shouldn't expect anything from anyone at 6am. That's ur time for ur morning routine to wake up.

pbc85 − NTA. But I don’t understand why you spent anytime at all debating this with her. “I’m going for my morning run. Bye!”

Academic_Nobody_4964 − NTA for your reasoning but maybe TAH in your delivery- especially if you knew how sensitive she is. You could’ve just said, I don’t usually eat breakfast before my runs and keeping this schedule is very important to my mental health.

ADVERTISEMENT

Also, you and your husband should come to an agreement on how to handle things like this going forward. He could’ve pushed his mom to having more of a “mother-son breakfast” to take the pressure off of you since he knows how important this is to you.

AuraOfHeroism − Light ESH. Talking once a week and visiting every other really isnt that clingly. Maybe if its supposed to be an all day thing every time. But barring that, her request for time doesnt seem crazy. Her I'm a guest thing rubs the wrong way and showing up unannounced was kinda rude so, hence ESH rating.

You could try to explain your mental health issues and explain why your routine is so important to you, but based on your wording, I'm gonna guess you haven't/won't. Shes being a bit pushy, but with no further details on toxic vehavior it really just sounds like she wants to spend time with you guys

ADVERTISEMENT

and you're being a bit of a jerk about it. (Again, no reasons given so not taking every possible situation into account, just the story we were told. Could be a million reasons why you wouldnt wanna spend time with her, but you didn't really list any)

immamoose-_- − NTA. You cannot be expected to drop everything on a whim for your MIL. Exercise is how you cope mentally and *she* should understand and respect *that*!

5thPLL − NTA First of all, congrats on having such a great morning routine and sticking to it as well as being so committed to your physical and mental health. Most people could do better to follow you in that - I absolutely include myself in that category as well. I’m really happy for you!

ADVERTISEMENT

Your MIL was way out of line. Even if she’s family, to show up out of the blue and expect you to alter your schedule is not normal behaviour. That she had meltdown because you weren’t up for paling around at 6AM is... so weird. You did nothing wrong and I don’t think statesmanship can be expected at 6AM, pre coffee, from anyone.

Depending on when your husband called you/got disturbed by her, he may also get a bit of a pass here, but ultimately he should still be on your side on this one. You’re his wife, and his mom was both out of line and really out there on a limb with how she thinks life works. He should apologise for blaming you, essentially for having very valid,. normal, and non offensive boundaries.c

These Reddit takes are bold, but do they nail the nuance? Family dynamics are tricky, and snap judgments might miss the heart of the issue.

ADVERTISEMENT

This early-morning standoff shows how quickly family visits can spiral when boundaries aren’t set. The OP’s commitment to their mental health routine clashed with their MIL’s unannounced plans, leaving hurt feelings in the dust. Clear communication—maybe a Dark Modea call ahead—could keep the peace. How would you handle a surprise visitor disrupting your sacred routine? Share your thoughts and strategies below!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *