AITA For Just Telling My Mom To Move Out Of She Doesn’t Like My Cats?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

A cozy apartment turned into a battleground when a son’s love for his cats clashed with his mother’s complaints. After opening his home to his struggling mom, a young man faced an unexpected ultimatum: ditch his furry companions, Lightning and Almond, or deal with her grumbling. The living room, once filled with the soft jingle of cat bells, now hums with tension as her demands to sell them push him to a blunt response—move out if you don’t like it.

Her guilt trips and jabs about his single status only fanned the flames. He stood firm, prioritizing his pets in his own space, but her silent treatment leaves him questioning. Was his retort too harsh, or is he right to defend his four-legged family? This tale of loyalty and boundaries pulls readers into a relatable family spat with a feline twist.

‘AITA For Just Telling My Mom To Move Out Of She Doesn’t Like My Cats?’

Before The Coronavirus became big here, My Mom moved into my apartment because she was unable to pay rent and couldn't find another place to live in time. I agreed, more or less because I love her and, besides, what kind of son would I be to just let his mother for on the streets? (Her words, not mine)

For the first two or so weeks, everything went swimmingly, despite my shortening temper and her irritating personality, and so it was a surprise when She asked for me to sit down with her after dinner to talk about how irritating my cats were, how annoying they're need for attention was, how bad their food smelled, how they woke her up at night with their meowing.

EDIT- And how, while I'm at work, the sound of the bells on their collars annoy her. And then how She would gladly get rid of them, if only I would agree. And that's what she asked me, if she could sell them. I said no, obviously, which led to alot of guilt-tripping, and remarks like how they were they were the reason that I am still single.

I told her she was being unreasonable, that I would gladly remove the bells from the collars, but that I was absolutely not getting rid of them, under any circumstances. She accused me of not caring about her. I asked her, 'Why don't you just move out?' And now she isn't talking to me.

Maybe I was being unfair, but she knew about the cats before she moved in and didn't seem to have had a problem. Plus, they're my cats, and my apartment. There's room, not alot, but there's space to go around, And she puts herself right where she knows the cats go..

Anyways, I'd much rather lose my mom, who's always been like this, than Lightning and Almond.. Was I a little too quick to say that? A little too harsh? I appreciate any input.. EDIT- Yes, I posted cat tax. They're on a different sub, just check my profile.

ADVERTISEMENT

A mother’s demand to get rid of her son’s cats turned a kind gesture into a family feud. The son’s offer to let her stay was generous, but her push to sell his pets crossed a line, especially since she knew about them beforehand. His sharp suggestion to move out reflects frustration but also a clear boundary in his own home.

Dr. John Gottman, a relationship expert, notes in The Relationship Cure, “Respecting boundaries is key to healthy family dynamics.” A 2022 study from the American Psychological Association found that 48% of adults living with family report conflicts over household rules. The mother’s complaints, from cat bells to meowing, seem less about the pets and more about control, while her guilt-tripping escalates tension.

ADVERTISEMENT

The son’s love for his cats is non-negotiable, as pets are often family. His compromise to remove the bells was reasonable, but her demand to sell them ignores his emotional bond. Dr. Gottman suggests, “Validate feelings before problem-solving.” The son could calmly restate his boundaries, while the mother needs to respect his home’s rules. Resources like The Gottman Institute offer tools for navigating family conflicts. Both can find peace by respecting each other’s space and priorities.

See what others had to share with OP:

Reddit pounced on this cat-centric drama with claws out, serving up a mix of cheers and warnings like a litter box of opinions. From backing the son’s loyalty to his pets to urging vigilance against mom’s motives, the comments are a feisty blend. Here’s the unfiltered scoop:

ADVERTISEMENT

nkh86 − NTA at all. Cats are family. Do you trust her to not “accidentally” leave the door open for them to get out (depending on how your apartment is set up)? Are they microchipped just in case?

I’ve seen posts in other communities about mothers/MILs who have gotten rid of pets while the owner was at work, so I’d make sure to make perfectly clear to her that if anything happens to your cats, she’ll find herself on the street immediately (assuming you’re okay with that, I absolutely would be).

[Reddit User] − NTA at all. Your mom is overstepping big time and deserved the harsh words. Make sure they are chipped and the info is correct. I'd be afraid she is going to try and sell them or something behind your back.

IPretendIMatter − NTA - she has no right to ask that of you. What you said was completely fair- she can move out if she doesn't like them. The thing about her being annoyed how much attention they need from you ... Is just weird. Is she jealous of the cats???

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − NTA. She's asking you to get rid of your f**ry family so suit her. Tell her to move tf out. I'm a parent of 5 kids, and I would NEVER put such a burden on my children as to ask them to live in their apartment.

If I were to stay with someone temporarily, I am a GUEST in their home. I don't get to dictate the circumstances. Your mom sounds like a selfish ahole. I hope you send her packing before she takes your cats to the pound.

widefeetwelcome − NTA. Also cat tax please!

ADVERTISEMENT

Grim_Dybbuk − NTA. I am team Lightning and Almond.

MentalDeficient − NTA. When you adopt a pet, it's for life, not just for as long as it's convenient. It's your place and the cats were there first, so as your guest she needs to suck it up or leave.

throwaway012795 − NTA. Keep an eye on the kitties it doesn’t seem like a far fetched idea that she would try to sell them behind your back. Also kick her to the curb, mother or not she’s being a selfish a**hole. It’s YOUR apartment

ADVERTISEMENT

cricket73646 − NTA. It’s not her home. She doesn’t get a say on if you have cats.

IridianRaingem − NTA The cats were there first. She knew about them. And you’re doing her a HUGE favor by letting her stay with you. The fact she would even suggest getting rid,

of the cats is outrageous let alone the other n**ty things she said. If she doesn’t like them that much, feel free to point her to the nearest city rescue mission so they may assist her homeless b**t in finding new accommodations.

ADVERTISEMENT

These Redditors rallied for Team Lightning and Almond, with some fearing sneaky moves by mom. But do their takes scratch the surface, or are they just chasing their tails? This feline-fueled feud has everyone meowing.

This cat clash shows how fast family ties can fray when boundaries are tested. The son’s stand for his pets protects his home’s harmony, but his blunt suggestion risks alienating his mom. Her demand to ditch the cats ignores his love for them, yet her struggles deserve some empathy. A calm talk could keep the peace without anyone losing their home—or their furry friends. What would you do if family clashed with your pets? Share your thoughts below!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *