AITA for refusing to forgive my ex so his mistress can “have” him?
In a quiet suburban home, the sting of betrayal lingers like an unwelcome guest. Three years ago, a woman’s world unraveled when her husband, citing marital struggles, asked for a break—only to plunge into an affair days later. Now, his girlfriend has emerged from the shadows, demanding forgiveness to free him from guilt and secure their future. The audacity sparks a fire in her chest, reigniting old wounds.
Why should she absolve a man who shattered her trust? Readers can’t help but lean in, wondering if she’s justified in standing her ground or if bitterness is clouding her judgment. This tale of heartbreak and boundaries pulls us into a messy, human conflict, where emotions clash and closure feels just out of reach.
‘AITA for refusing to forgive my ex so his mistress can “have” him?’
This tangled tale of infidelity and guilt is a stark reminder that trust, once broken, leaves scars that don’t easily fade. The woman’s refusal to forgive her ex-husband reflects a deep need for self-preservation, while his girlfriend’s bold demand highlights a clash of perspectives. He seeks absolution; she seeks peace. Both are valid, yet neither owes the other closure.
Dr. John Gottman, a renowned relationship expert, notes, “Trust is built in very small moments, and when those are betrayed, rebuilding is a choice, not an obligation”. The woman’s choice to block contact aligns with protecting her emotional health. Infidelity, even during a “break,” often violates unspoken marital commitments—63% of Americans view such acts as cheating, per a 2018 YouGov poll.
The broader issue here is emotional accountability. The ex-husband’s guilt may stall his new relationship, but projecting that onto his ex-wife sidesteps his responsibility. The girlfriend’s frustration, while human, misplaces blame. For the woman, setting boundaries is key—therapists often recommend no-contact policies post-divorce to foster healing. She might consider therapy to process lingering pain, ensuring her strength doesn’t mask unresolved hurt.
Here’s what Redditors had to say:
Reddit’s peanut gallery didn’t hold back, serving up a mix of fiery support and sly humor. Here’s a taste of their candid takes, proving the internet never lacks opinions on love and loyalty.
But do these spicy Reddit quips hold up in the real world? Or are they just armchair therapists tossing out hot takes?
This story leaves us pondering the weight of forgiveness and the power of boundaries. The woman’s choice to block her ex and his girlfriend isn’t just about holding a grudge—it’s about reclaiming her peace. Forgiveness is personal, not a ticket for others to move on. What would you do if faced with a similar demand? Share your thoughts—have you ever had to draw a hard line to protect your heart?
