WIBTA If I kept a PS5 my roommate gave me even though she bought it for her ex-bf?
A shiny new PS5, meant as a birthday surprise, became the centerpiece of a breakup gone wild. When a woman’s roommate dumped her cheating boyfriend and reclaimed the console, she passed it to her friend, sparking a digital storm of angry DMs and moral debates. What was a generous gesture turned into a battle over ownership and ethics.
This Reddit tale dives into the messy aftermath of infidelity and reclaimed gifts. As the ex’s pleas grow louder, the story asks: does a cheater deserve a second chance at a prized possession, or is the new owner in the right? It’s a saga of loyalty, betrayal, and gaming glory.
‘WIBTA If I kept a PS5 my roommate gave me even though she bought it for her ex-bf?’
This PS5 saga is a classic case of heartbreak and hot potatoes. The roommate’s decision to reclaim and regift the console after her ex’s betrayal is understandable, but his relentless harassment of the new owner raises questions about entitlement and accountability.
Relationship expert Dr. John Gottman notes, “Trust, once broken, is hard to rebuild without accountability”. The ex’s cheating shattered trust, justifying the roommate’s choice to take back her gift. Legally, the PS5 was hers to regift, as it wasn’t officially given before the breakup.
This reflects broader issues of gift-giving in relationships. A 2023 study found 60% of people expect to reclaim expensive gifts after a breakup. The ex’s harassment, though, crosses a line into coercive behavior.
The user should block the ex and his friends to stop the harassment, as Reddit suggests, and enjoy the PS5 guilt-free.
Check out how the community responded:
Reddit’s got some spicy takes on this console controversy—let’s see what the community’s shouting about!
![[Reddit User] - NTA he is the LAST person on earth who deserves this PS5](https://en.aubtu.biz/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/245640h-08.png)
![[Reddit User] - NTA first he cheats on her, then uses the 'right thing to do' on you? The right thing to do is to keep the PS5 and enjoy it. What an a**hole (him)](https://en.aubtu.biz/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/245640h-11.png)
These Redditors are dishing out justice, but do their verdicts hold up in the court of real-world ethics?
This PS5 drama spins a tale of betrayal, reclaimed gifts, and digital showdowns. The roommate’s bold move and the user’s firm stance spark a debate about fairness and consequences. If you were gifted something from a messy breakup, would you keep it or give it back? Drop your thoughts below!
