AITA for posting anniversary photos including a cheater?

Step into a nostalgic anniversary celebration, where old wedding photos stir up fresh drama. A woman shares throwback snaps featuring her husband’s groomsman, Harry, and his date, Sally, from years ago. But Harry, who was cheating on his now-partner, Mary, with Sally at the time, begs her to remove the photos, citing Mary’s discomfort.

Refusing to edit her cherished memories, the woman stands firm, igniting Harry’s complaints and a debate over loyalty and social media boundaries. Reddit’s buzzing with takes on whether her choice was fair or a jab too far.

‘AITA for posting anniversary photos including a cheater?’

Social media can reopen old wounds, as this woman found when her anniversary photos upset her husband’s groomsman, Harry, and his partner, Mary. Harry’s cheating past—dating Sally while seeing Mary—makes the photos a sore spot, but the woman’s refusal to remove them is rooted in their personal significance. Harry’s request, while understandable, shifts blame from his actions to her celebration, creating unfair pressure. Her husband’s indifference suggests the issue lies with Harry and Mary’s unresolved feelings.

A 2024 Journal of Social and Personal Relationships study notes 60% of couples face tension over past relationships resurfacing online, often due to unaddressed guilt. Psychologist Dr. Stan Tatkin advises, “Own your past choices rather than policing others’ memories.” Harry could untag himself or discuss his discomfort privately, while Mary’s upset reflects her unresolved trust issues, not the woman’s actions.

For similar conflicts, experts suggest open dialogue to clarify intentions—here, the woman could explain the photos’ importance. Others might set social media boundaries, like private albums, to avoid drama. The woman’s stand preserves her autonomy, but a heads-up to Harry might have softened the blow.

Let’s dive into the reactions from Reddit:

Reddit poured out support and sharp takes for this photo-posting woman. Here’s what they snapped back:

These takes spark a question: was her refusal to edit the photos a fair stand, or did it needlessly stir the pot?

This anniversary photo fracas shows how past betrayals can haunt present joys. The woman’s choice to keep her wedding photos intact, despite Harry’s cheating scandal, was a stand for her memories, but it ruffled feathers. Was she right to prioritize her nostalgia, or should she have considered Mary’s feelings? How would you navigate a friend’s plea to erase their past from your photos? Drop your thoughts below and let’s keep the convo flashing!