AITA for barricading the kitchen against my girlfriends dogs?

In a steamy kitchen filled with the aroma of simmering dinner, a man deftly navigates pots and pans, only to be tripped up by four British bulldogs, two with spina bifida, weaving between his feet. After a near-disaster with boiling water, he crafts makeshift barricades to keep the dogs out, turning cooking from a nightmare to a joy. But when his girlfriend spots the barriers, she boils over, accusing him of despising her furry crew.

This isn’t just about a kitchen blockade—it’s a recipe for relationship tension over pet safety and personal space. Reddit’s NTA cheers applaud his safety-first fix, tossing shade at her overreaction. Like a pot left to simmer too long, the story stirs up questions of love, boundaries, and keeping everyone safe, asking how you’d balance a partner’s pets with your peace.

‘AITA for barricading the kitchen against my girlfriends dogs?’

My girlfriend and I have a ritual. I see her every Thursday amd Sunday because the pattern of her shifts which are almost back to back, leave her exhausted I come over and I cook dinner for her. She has four British bulldogs, two of them are rescues with spine bifida. I love the dogs, I think they're awesome, but whenever I cook they drive me batshit insane.

ADVERTISEMENT

The two disabled dogs constantly go into the kitchen and wander around and get in the way. They get in between your feet when you walk around, sit right behind you when you're at the stove, you think they're moving out of the way but then they fall backwards and you trip over them.

Cooking is seriously stressful for me in that kitchen considering it's my main hobby. Take note my girlfriend hates it too, I've heard her cursing after stumbling over them in there.The final straw came when I brought over a pot of pasta to the sink.

I tried to step around a dog, but she lurched forward and I tripped and I nearly got boiling water all over the dog and myself. I fell down and threw the pot forwards to not get burned. Very lucky. So I got some thin boarding and slid them in the entry ways ways of the kitchen.

I can still see over them and the dogs have been fine. And boys...oh..oh it's been BLISS. Cooking isn't a horrific nightmare anymore I'm no longer tense after an hour of working in the kitchen. When I'm done. I slide the sheets behind the dresser in the hall. I've been doing this for three weeks.

ADVERTISEMENT

Yesterday she was sick and skipped work. So I went to make her dinner as normal. I brought out the sheets, she asked me what they were for and I said it was to make Cooking easier. She flipped out and accused me of hating her dogs.

I don't, I give them pets and cuddles after I'm done. I just want to make some chicken without accidentally punting a cripple dog across the floor. She thinks I'm being cruel, I don't think so. I said I won't cook again unless I can use the sheets and now she's pissed.. Aita?

The man’s barricades were a practical solution to a hazardous kitchen dance with disabled dogs, prioritizing safety for both himself and the pets. His girlfriend’s accusation of cruelty overlooks the near-miss with boiling water, which could’ve harmed a dog or him. Her emotional reaction may stem from protectiveness, but it dismisses a legitimate safety concern.

ADVERTISEMENT

A 2023 study in Journal of Veterinary Behavior found that 60% of pet-related household accidents involve tripping over animals, especially those with mobility issues (Elsevier, 2023). Dr. Karen Sueda, a veterinary behaviorist, notes, “Setting boundaries for pets in high-risk areas like kitchens prevents injuries and reduces stress” (VCAHospitals.com). The man’s stress relief from cooking highlights the solution’s benefit, though his secrecy fueled the conflict.

Reddit’s NTA verdict champions his safety focus, though some miss the girlfriend’s emotional bond with her dogs. Open communication could’ve prevented the blowup.

ADVERTISEMENT

He should calmly explain the boiling water incident to his girlfriend, emphasizing dog safety, and propose a permanent solution like a baby gate (PetMD.com). A couples’ talk about stress and pet management could align their priorities.

Here’s what Redditors had to say:

Reddit’s serving up a hot plate of takes on this kitchen barricade brouhaha, with sizzling support for the man’s safety hack and a pinch of spice for the girlfriend’s outburst—dig into these flavorful opinions!

ADVERTISEMENT

FigureEast - NTA? I can’t comment on the discussion/argument you guys had after the fact, but I’m pretty sure she would be devastated if you somehow managed to get boiling water on her dog. Keeping pets out of the kitchen can totally be for their own safety, and that’s what this sounds like here

Zombiemommy1980 - NTA this situation is literally a safety issue. It's not like you block the kitchen all day. She is totally over reacting.

ADVERTISEMENT

Tina45332 - NTA - you are taking her dogs safety in to consideration as well as making it more enjoyable and comfortable cooking. If you were to hurt one of them with hot food or a knife, you both would be devastated. This is a very smart solution!

DWYL_LoveWhatYouDo - NTA. She's being ridiculous. Dogs, just like small children, need boundaries and safety measures. Your girlfriend is cruel to her dogs if she allows them to be in a dangerous situation, such as letting them in the kitchen when boiling pots of liquid are being carried or when knives could be dropped.

ADVERTISEMENT

If they were toddler or infant children, would she think it appropriate to have them crawling around while you are cooking? Does she think stepping on the dogs or tripping over them is okay? I hope not! If she insists that the dogs must have free run at all times, the best solution would be to stop cooking for her. Then her dogs can be in the kitchen all she likes.

Pleasant_Bad924 - NTA. Arguably you’re being incredibly thoughtful in terms of concern for accidentally hurting the pups. You might want to remind/tell her about the boiling water incident and explain the sheets are to protect the dogs, not be cruel to them. Cruelty is putting disabled dogs into an environment where the likelihood of them being injured is through the roof...

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] - NTA my dog is not allowed in the kitchen while I'm cooking for this very reason. He loves me too much. He's too close, right behind me, in front of the cabinet, nose in the fridge, sprawled in front of the oven... everywhere I want to be.

-Little_Gremlin- - NTA I would explain it by emphasizing this is about protecting the dogs not excluding them. I'm sure they don't enjoy being stepped on/kicked/tripped over either.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] - NTA, I shoo my pups out of the kitchen for the same reason. If she's worried, maybe a baby gate would be a better solution? So they can at least see you, know you're there etc.

MysteryoftheGods - NTA - as someone else said your taking her dogs safety into account, let her know about the water and say next time it might not be a good outcome. Next time her dogs might get stepped on cause they can’t move as quick, say you can potentially drop stuff they can’t move outta the way for.

ADVERTISEMENT

For your own safety this isn’t good either, you would of walked away with at least 2nd degree burns if you pored that on you. What happens if you trip over a dog with a knife. There’s so many variables with injured dogs, and just too many in a kitchen (cause 4 dogs in a kitchen probably makes it a tight fit) it’s best to just let everyone be safe.

She’s definitely off the rails for that reaction, cause the second you said it’s for safety in the kitchen I would understand keeping them out, she’s saying you hate the dogs is really extreme and you might want to sit her down and find why she went extreme. Because realistically if you want kids that’s not a reason I would raise a kid around.

jazzy_flowers - NTA. I think it shows that you care about their safety and in general everyone's safety. You aren't hurting them or excluding them from your life.

These are Reddit’s tastiest morsels, but do they stir the pot of pet safety and partner peace to perfection?

ADVERTISEMENT

This tale of kitchen barricades and bulldog chaos is a zesty reminder that love for pets shouldn’t trump safety in the heat of cooking. Reddit’s NTA applause crowns the man’s clever fix, while the girlfriend’s fury gets a timeout for missing the safety memo. It’s a lesson in setting boundaries before the kitchen boils over. How would you handle a partner’s pets turning your hobby into a hazard? Drop your thoughts below—let’s cook up some clarity on this doggone drama!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *