Aita for asking my sister to stop wearing revealing clothes around my fiance?

In a cozy apartment, a 22-year-old woman opens her home to her newly divorced sister, Mia, expecting sisterly support. But when Mia swaps modest threads for skimpy outfits and flirty moves whenever her fiancé visits, the vibe sours fast. From suggestive banana-eating to “accidental” drops, Mia’s antics push the couple’s comfort zone, prompting a blunt sit-down that explodes into a social media rant accusing the woman of sexism.

This isn’t just about wardrobe choices—it’s a showdown over respect and boundaries. Reddit’s NTA brigade rallies behind the woman, roasting Mia’s brazen behavior. Like a guest overstaying their welcome, the story dives into the messy clash of family loyalty and personal space, asking how you’d handle a sibling crossing the line with your partner.

‘Aita for asking my sister to stop wearing revealing clothes around my fiance?’

My sister (31) recently went through a divorce so I (22) allowed her to stay at my apartment until she gets back on her feet. My sister let's call her Mia usually wear modest clothing but every time my fiance comes around she changes up her clothes into way more revealing ones,

ADVERTISEMENT

I mean she doesn't even try to be subtle and will change if my fiance comes around unexpectedly even If it's in the middle of the day from clothe that are more modest into clothes that are revealing.

My fiance started noticing it as well and it makes him uncomfortable, he told me on many different occasions that Mia will do stuff like dorp something on purpose and pick it up back side facing my fiance or eat a banana very seductively while looking my fiance in the eyes.

I thought he was joking at first but I witnessed it with my very own eyes, I mean I understand she's going through hard time after her divorce or what not but this is honestly ridiculous. So I sat Mia down and explained to her that her actions are making me and my fiance uncomfortable and I'd appreciate if she'd stop and I listed all the weird things she been doing.

She was extremely offended by it and claimed that I am sexest and that she should be able to wear what she pleases when she pleases. Went on Facebook and made a post about our discussion claiming that I'm overly jealous sexest and insecure and can't handle being around a big girl.

ADVERTISEMENT

My mom thinks that I should allow her to continue dressing like that in front of my fiance because she think Mia is under alot of stress. I feel like she's being inappropriate and I feel as if she's being disrespectful, I been trying my best to help her through her separation with her husband,

I allowed into my house and I allow her to have my niece and nephew over the weekends and even watch my niece and nephew when needed. I don't understand what I have done for her to act in such disrespect towards me.. Aita for asking my sister to cover up more infont of my husband.

The woman’s request for Mia to tone down her revealing outfits and flirty behavior was a fair defense of her relationship’s boundaries. Mia’s actions—changing clothes for the fiancé and provocative gestures—suggest deliberate disrespect, not just personal style. Her social media outburst and “sexism” claim deflect accountability, escalating a private issue into public drama.

ADVERTISEMENT

A 2023 study in Journal of Social and Personal Relationships found that 67% of family conflicts involve boundary violations, often worsened by unresolved emotional stress like divorce (Sage Journals, 2023). Dr. Terri Orbuch, a relationship expert, notes, “Houseguests must respect the host’s comfort, especially around romantic partners, to maintain trust” (TheLoveDoctor.com). Mia’s post-divorce turmoil doesn’t justify her behavior, which risks alienating her sister’s support.

Reddit’s NTA verdict nails Mia’s overstep, though some miss the woman’s generosity in hosting her. Mia’s stress is real, but her actions aren’t excused.

ADVERTISEMENT

The woman should set clear house rules, like no outfit changes for guests, and consider a move-out timeline (PsychologyToday.com). A neutral mediator, like a family counselor, could address Mia’s defensiveness. The fiancé should reinforce boundaries by limiting visits.

Here’s what Redditors had to say:

Reddit’s dishing out a sizzling platter of takes on this sister’s wardrobe switcheroo, with shade for Mia’s flirt fest and cheers for the couple’s stand—grab a forkful of these juicy opinions!

ADVERTISEMENT

ParsimoniousSalad - NTA. She is being incredibly disrespectful of you and your husband, and it's frankly creepy and embarrassing for her. Your house, your rules. You've told her her behavior makes you both uncomfortable and is inappropriate. She needs to stop or leave. Period. Doesn't matter how much 'stress' she is under. Your mother can host her if she feels differently.

FoolMe1nceShameOnU - NTA but you're going at this from the wrong angle. You need to stop acting as though this is a level playing field where your sister's ridiculousness might actually tempt your fiance, and make it clear to her that the problem here isn't her immodesty, it's that she's embarrassing herself, and you feel sorry for her.

ADVERTISEMENT

It's a cruel thing to have to do, and not one I would usually suggest because it requires that you be mean. But at this point you have tried compassion and gentleness and she came back at you with utter disrespect and rudeness. She no longer deserves the kindness you have shown her. So be honest. Explain to her that she's right, that she can dress however she likes.

But that your fiance isn't interested in her, and that each and every time she makes one of these blatant attempts at being seductive around him, the discomfort you both feel isn't jealousy (from you) or attraction (from him) but pity (from both of you) because he isn't remotely attracted to her, and her desperation is incredibly unflattering and pitiful.

ADVERTISEMENT

You love her, she's your sister, and you just really want to see her have more self-respect than to act like a thirst-trap around her own utterly disinterested brother-in-law, because she's so much better than that, and it's so heartbreaking to see. Maybe that will finally get through to her.

ShinyGallinule - NTA. Kick her out. Kick her out NOW. I don’t give a damn about the dumpster fire that’ll start online. No one should be s**ually harassed in their own home. That’s the real sexist part about this. If it was a woman being s**ually harassed by her fiancé’s brother this would be seen as totally different.

ADVERTISEMENT

No-Jellyfish-1208 - NTA. It must feel quite cringy to observe her behaviour. Also, is your fiancé the last man on this planet or what? Can't she find any other new man to seduce?

[Reddit User] - NTA She's hitting on your fiancé. I wouldn't allow someone who behaved like that to stay with me.

ADVERTISEMENT

shiningci - NTA. The issue isn't her wearing whatever she wants. The issue is that she is hitting on your fiance and no amount of stress makes that justifiable. You are doing her a favor and she repays it by going after your fiance? Ugh.

BingandBong123 - NTA, but the clothes are not the real issue here, her blatantly flirting with your fiancé is. Asking her to cover up isn't going to tackle the root of the problem

ADVERTISEMENT

HereFishyFishy4444 - NTA. It's not sexist, because it doesn't seem to be about her dressing simply the way she likes, but it's about her deliberately changing when your fiance comes around. Besides, it's really pretty harsh to try and get this kind of attention from her sister's fiance, someone who took her in when she needed a place. Don't worry, you're good.

Melodic-Narwhal-582 - NTA, and since your mom thinks this is ok behavior then Mia should probably move in with her.

Stank_Floyd - NTA. Best solution is to point it out each time: 'Look Doug, you can see Mia's gash through her clothes. Looks like a bullet wound, right? Can also make out her hairy pancake nipples. You think she'll deep throat a carrot for you?'

These are Reddit’s spiciest slices, but do they carve out the full truth of sisterly bonds and boundary lines?

ADVERTISEMENT

This tale of a sister’s skimpy outfits and a fiancé’s unease is a bold reminder that family ties don’t trump respect in your own home. Reddit’s NTA applause crowns the woman’s call-out, tossing Mia’s flirtatious antics into the hot seat. It’s a lesson in drawing lines before the guest room becomes a battleground. How would you handle a sibling turning your safe space into a stage for seduction? Share your thoughts below—let’s untangle this family fashion fiasco!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *