AITA for telling my GF she isn’t allowed to use my eggs because she wastes them?

The kitchen counter held a precious carton of eggs, a rare find in a country gripped by a bird flu crisis. For one 25-year-old, these eggs were a shared treasure with his girlfriend—until her habit of tossing egg whites sparked a feud. What seemed like a small quirk ballooned into a test of compromise and respect in their shared home.

Her yolk-only noodle routine left him frustrated, especially when he could use the whites for baking. His plea to save them was ignored, leading to a bold ultimatum: buy your own eggs or stop wasting mine. Her fiery response turned a simple food dispute into a Reddit-worthy saga, raising questions about fairness, waste, and partnership in tough times.

‘AITA for telling my GF she isn’t allowed to use my eggs because she wastes them?’

Hello. I will make things short. Me and my gf (both 25) have been fighting over eggs recently. There is a egg crisis in my country. A lot of hens have died from a bird flu. This has made eggs a rarity in our local supermarket and they are both hard to get by and more expensive. You are lucky if you are able to buy a packet of eggs before they run out.

We eat a lot of egg in our household and share our finances but I do all the grocery shopping now during the pandemic. My GF only eats the egg yolk (puts in on her noodles) and throws away the egg whites. I like the whites and use them both in baking and in normal cooking.

I keep telling her that I think it's unfair she throws away the whites, and have asked her to at least save the whites in the fridge so that I can use it later. I get upset that she's wasting edible parts of a food thats hard to come by, and even if the egg crisis wasnt in action I think she's being upsetting in the way she just throws away edible food like that.

I told her that I will start to buy eggs from my own savings and she won't be allowed to take from my egg box unless she saves the whites. She freaked out at me since she wants to use the egg yolks for her noodles. She says I am being an a**hole and petty about this, since its just eggs.

I dont know if she's right or not because yes its just eggs but since its just eggs she could just as well not throw them away like that when it causes such a disturbance to our relationship? This is very upsetting to me and I want to know if I am overreacting and am being an a**hole for making her save the whites or not have any yolks.

Eggs, once a kitchen staple, became a battleground for this couple. The boyfriend’s frustration stems from his girlfriend’s refusal to save egg whites, a small act that looms large in a shortage. Her dismissal—calling it “just eggs”—clashes with his practical need to maximize scarce resources, revealing a deeper disconnect in their approach to shared responsibilities.

Food waste is a global issue, amplified in crises. A 2021 FAO report notes that 14% of food produced is lost before reaching consumers, with household waste a key contributor (source). This couple’s egg dispute mirrors broader tensions over resource use, especially when scarcity heightens stakes.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dr. Dana Gunders, a food waste expert, states, “Small actions, like saving edible food parts, can shift mindsets toward sustainability” (source). Her insight suggests the girlfriend’s wastefulness isn’t just about eggs—it’s a missed chance to align with her partner’s values. His compromise to save whites was reasonable; her resistance hints at inflexibility.

Couples facing similar conflicts can benefit from open dialogue about shared goals. Setting clear rules—like storing separated egg parts—can prevent waste and resentment. If scarcity persists, exploring yolk-free recipes together could ease tension. This story underscores that compromise, not control, keeps partnerships cooking smoothly.

ADVERTISEMENT

Here’s what Redditors had to say:

Reddit dished out some cracking opinions, blending humor with sharp takes. Here’s the community’s scramble of thoughts:

Fickle_Ostrich4923 − NTA, it's super weird that she refuses to just save the egg whites for you. Wouldn't be a difficult thing at all.

ADVERTISEMENT

beans_and_rice − NTA. It's barely any extra effort for her to put the whites *that she has already separated from the yolk* into a bowl in the fridge for later use. She's literally already done the hardest part. It is very selfish (and mind boggling) behaviour on her end. The fact that there's a shortage of eggs just makes it worse.

bubbleuj − NTA. She says I am being an a**hole and petty about this, since its just eggs.. Then she can buy the eggs she wants to use for her hobby then. It takes no time at all to just empty the whites into a container for you. She’s being weird about this.. EDIT: I misread noodles as hobby lmao

eatmoreunicorns − NTA. What is her reason for not putting the whites back in the fridge for you to use? You said you'd be okay with that. It would be just as easy for her to save them as it is to throw them away. She's being ridiculous about it.

Standard_Engineer724 − NTA - I don't understand how people can throw away perfectly fine food even without a crisis. Her disregard for your concerns and wished is alarming. It's literally not more bothersome to place the container she used to separate the eggs in the fridge that to throw them away

ADVERTISEMENT

Kewege − NTA- It’s no skin off her nose to save them. If she wants to waste a big part of an egg she can waste it on the eggs she buys.

aliquilts71 − NTA. We don’t even have an egg crisis in our country but I regularly save the yolks or whites if I’ve only needed to use one or the other. If she has to buy eggs (and can’t get them) she might realise how wasteful she’s being.

Throwaway51276 − NTA. The egg whites are just as useful as the yolk and if she can't see the benefit in that and is just wasting them then you've every right to be upset and ban her use of them.

ADVERTISEMENT

Pseudo-Data − NTA - assuming you save the yolks for her when you use just the whites for baking and cooking.

youhidethebody − NTA. I say she’s being stuck up like it needs to just be her way. You are trying to compromise and she is straight refusing and getting mad at you. I believe your point about it just being eggs either decision made it’s still just eggs, what bothers me most about this point is it’s just eggs.

What happens when eggs turn into furniture, vehicles, a new place to live, hell would she compromise for a wedding? I’m not saying you’re that serious or that things need to end but I would say you need to seriously take a step back and see if it’s this one thing or something more. Best of luck!

ADVERTISEMENT

These spicy takes beg the question: is it really “just eggs,” or a sign of bigger cracks in the relationship? Reddit’s verdict leans hard into practicality.

This egg saga whisks up a lesson in compromise and respect. In a time of scarcity, the girlfriend’s wastefulness scrambled her boyfriend’s patience, turning a carton of eggs into a symbol of partnership. It’s a reminder that small actions—like saving a bit of food—can mean a lot. Have you ever clashed over household habits? What would you do in this egg-treme situation? Drop your thoughts below!

Share this post
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *