AITA For telling my sister she’s free to criticize my work as soon as she accomplishes anything in life without our parents holding her hand?

Jonathan Hours
Comments 0 Comments

Picture a lively family dinner, where birthday cake and old grudges simmer. A hardworking woman, proud of her self-made path, beams as she shares her passion for teaching creative writing. But her younger sister, coddled by their parents’ endless support, lobs a cutting jab, dimming the celebration’s glow. Her sharp retort—pointing out her sister’s lack of independent achievements—sets the table ablaze with tension.

This Reddit tale crackles with sibling rivalry and unspoken resentment. Years of parental favoritism fuel a clash that’s as relatable as it is fiery. With a pinch of humor and a heap of heart, we dive into a story where one woman’s stand for respect stirs a family debate. Who’s in the wrong here?

‘AITA For telling my sister she’s free to criticize my work as soon as she accomplishes anything in life without our parents holding her hand?’

While our parents loved me (30F) and my younger sister, Olivia (27F), we were not treated equally or held to the same standards. I always was expected to be a hardworking, accountable child and make responsible choices. But Olivia was encouraged to have fun, and our parents bailed her out whenever she made an irresponsible decision.

ADVERTISEMENT

For example, when Olivia performed poorly in school due to not making an effort, they would pay tutors to do her homework. But if I genuinely struggled in a subject, they would tell me to figure it out myself. Their justification was that Olivia was the baby sister, and she needed more help and attention than I did.

But they have still clung to this excuse when Olivia is well into adulthood. I still love my parents, but due to their favoritism, I am honestly closer with my husband's parents than with my own. My parents helped financially with the first two years of college then I had to cover the rest of my bachelor's and master's degrees by myself.

They financially supported all of Olivia's education. Olivia wanted to become an RN, just like our mother and grandma. But she could not pass most of her general education courses and eventually dropped out because she said it was too hard for her. Olivia then convinced our parents to invest a massive amount of money in her to begin a business.

ADVERTISEMENT

She owned a store that sold things like candles and bath bombs, but the store went bankrupt after a year. Currently, Olivia is unemployed and living with our parents; She claims she is 'figuring herself out,' which means she is mainly partying and spending time with her high school friends. Olivia is upset because many of her old friends are no longer in the area.

She will call me to express her disappointment because her friends are moving on with lives and families of their own, and they have less and less time for her. I tell Olivia I am sorry to hear that and that I have to hang up soon. We celebrated my son's second birthday with a family dinner. I was talking with my aunt-in-law about my students.

I work as a creative writing tutor on the side to pick up some extra money. I help my students with world-building and whatever else they need help with in their stories. My students are all passionate people with genuinely good ideas. And it feels as if we're just having a conversation.

ADVERTISEMENT

Olivia joined and asked a few questions, then commented, 'Not like you would ever be able to make it big yourself. No offense, sis.' I responded, 'Livvy, a quick reminder that you have accomplished **nothing** in your life without mom or dad holding your hand. As soon as you do, you can criticize my work all you'd like.'

Olivia was, of course, offended and started causing a scene. My parents and a few other relatives said my response was cruel, and I was out of line to say it. But my husband and his family say that Olivia invited it after insulting me first, so I am conflicted about if I am in the wrong. I am hoping for some unbiased perspectives.

This sibling spat isn’t just about a snarky comment—it’s a flare-up of deep-seated family dynamics. The older sister’s frustration stems from years of parental favoritism, which has left Olivia unmotivated and entitled. Family therapist Dr. John Gottman notes, “Favoritism creates resentment and undermines sibling bonds” (Gottman Institute). The older sister’s retort, while harsh, reflects a need to assert her hard-earned independence against Olivia’s unearned criticism.

ADVERTISEMENT

Favoritism’s impact is well-documented: a 2020 study in the Journal of Family Psychology found that perceived parental bias increases sibling conflict by 45% (APA PsycNet). Olivia’s academic and business failures, cushioned by parental support, contrast sharply with her sister’s self-reliant success. Her insult—dismissing her sister’s career—mirrors a pattern of entitlement, as she’s never faced consequences for her actions.

The broader issue is enabling dependency in adulthood. Olivia’s unemployment and reliance on her parents at 27 suggest a lack of accountability, often fostered by overprotective parenting. Dr. Gottman advises setting boundaries to encourage growth, noting that coddling can stunt emotional maturity.

Advice: The older sister should initiate a calm conversation with Olivia, addressing the insult and their differing paths without blame. Family therapy could help untangle favoritism’s roots.

ADVERTISEMENT

These are the responses from Reddit users:

Reddit’s crew didn’t hold back, dishing out a feast of fiery takes and cheeky quips. From calls for tough love to nods of solidarity, here’s what they served up:

Haunting-Row-3961 − NTA. So she can dish it but cannot take it??

buffooncocktail − NTA. Chat s**t, get banged. As they used to say at my school…

ADVERTISEMENT

MamaKilla20 − NTA It was cruel. But she needed it. I've got to stop with the 'be nice', 'be the bigger' person BS. you've been doing it your whole life. Of course your family will say you're TA, they've spoiled her all this time. Don't feel bad OP and be a little egoistic from now on. You deserve it.

Lifear − NTA, a bit brutal, but she did deserve it.

Reddit_Gunboat − NTA.. I feel like Olivia started it with her mean comment to you. All you did was finish it.

ADVERTISEMENT

ParamedicSilent2097 − NTA I don't think it was even mean....it was a simple statement of fact. You can be proud that everything you have achieved is due to your own endeavours, your own strength. Your sister, even with your parent's support, both financial and emotional, has achieved nothing, and will be more of a burden as your parents age.

Dark_Energy88 − NTA. as an older sister myself I have also been treated less favourably by my parents than my sister has. My sister has made comments to me that I’ve thrown back at her regarding various things in which the situation was almost the same as yours.

If your sister depends so heavily on your parents to bail her out and babysit her she has no right to criticise you. She is the AH for thinking she can say those things to you when she has nothing to show for her life when you clearly do. So no, you are NTA

ADVERTISEMENT

firetothetrees − NTA... Play stupid games and get stupid prizes... Your sister has been playing stupid games for a while and finally got called out. You rock!

TarantulaTornado − NTA your parents have ruined her by spoiling and coddling her behavior. My parents did the same thing with my younger sister and are now paying the price for it (she uses her kids as weapons to get what she wants out of them).

They get upset when I tell them it's their fault and I don't want to hear them complain about it. Your sister is never going to be able to take care of herself and if she can't take any criticism then she shouldn't dish it out.

ADVERTISEMENT

sarcosaurus − NTA. If she can dish it out, she can take it. Did anyone notice she proved your point by not even being able to handle one critical remark without running to mommy and daddy for help? Also, her insult was worse. She told you you'd never 'make it big' like it was an irreversible fact - you at least left room for the possibility that she might accomplish something in the future.

These Reddit zingers are piping hot, but do they cut to the core of this sisterly showdown? Is it just a spat, or a symptom of deeper family flaws?

This family dinner dust-up reveals a tale of favoritism and frustration. The older sister’s sharp clapback, born of years forging her own path, exposes Olivia’s reliance on parental crutches. Reddit cheers her stand, but the rift lingers. If your sibling took a cheap shot at your hard-won success, how would you respond? Toss your thoughts into the mix—let’s keep this family feud cooking!

ADVERTISEMENT
Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *