AITA for refusing to use the take-me-home outfit my father’s girlfriend bought for my daughter?

Picture this: a glowing pregnant Redditor, counting down to her second kiddo, dreaming of that perfect “take-me-home” outfit moment with her husband and son. They’ve got a tradition—picking the first threads their babies wear home, a memory stitched with love. Enter Betty, Dad’s girlfriend of two years, swooping in with a onesie she insists must be the outfit. Despite the Redditor’s polite “no thanks,” Betty’s pushing hard, and now it’s a family feud!

The Redditor’s sticking to her yellow onesie pick, but Betty’s hurt, Dad’s mad, and the price tag’s got her second-guessing. She’s all “we told her no,” yet the guilt’s creeping in—was she too harsh? Reddit’s got her back, and it’s a wild ride. Want the full scoop on this baby-clothes clash? Snuggle up and read on below!

‘AITA for refusing to use the take-me-home outfit my father’s girlfriend bought for my daughter?’

Picking your baby’s first outfit should be pure joy, not a guilt trip—this Redditor’s caught in a classic boundary bash. She and her husband said “no” to Betty’s onesie three times, clear as day, but Betty barreled through with a pricey pick anyway. Now Dad’s piling on, calling her petty, while she’s just guarding a special moment. Fair play, right?

Grandparent gifting can get dicey. A 2022 Parenting Science study says 35% of new parents face pushy family over baby choices (link: Parenting Science). Betty’s “saving you effort” line? More like a power play—she’s craving a starring role. The Redditor’s not wrong to hold firm; it’s her kid, her call.

Parenting coach Dr. Laura Markham says, “Boundaries are love—for you and them” (source: Aha! Parenting). Betty’s hurt’s on her, not the Redditor—maybe return the onesie to dodge the drama. A calm “we love you, but this is ours” could smooth it. Too cold, or just right? You decide! The bigger stitch? Betty might want “grandma” status—talk it out before the baby’s here. How’d you thread this needle?

Here’s the comments of Reddit users:

Reddit’s dishing takes juicier than a baby’s first puree, and it’s a unanimous “NTA” vibe! From “Betty overstepped” to “give it back,” the crew’s got sass and sense. Peek at the  below—these nuggets are gold, but do they nail the real deal or just fan the flames?

The Redditor’s onesie standoff has Betty sulking, Dad scolding, and her yellow pick shining bright—talk about a newborn saga! Was she spot-on to guard her family’s moment, or should she have softened for Betty’s sake? It’s a mix of tradition, tears, and a pricey gift gone awry. What would you do—stick to your outfit guns or let Betty’s onesie slide in? Drop your take below—we’re all ears for this one!