My (29M) friend (28F) told me she doesn’t want her child to spend time alone with me because of my stammer. I’m unsure what I should do?

In a moment meant for joy, a 29-year-old man’s heart sinks. Offering to babysit his close friend’s newborn, he’s met with a stinging rebuff: she fears her baby might “pick up” his stammer. Despite their decade-long bond and his expertise with children, her words cut deep, leaving him questioning their friendship and his place in her new family.

This isn’t just about a misunderstanding; it’s a raw clash of friendship and ableism rooted in ignorance. Readers will feel his shock, rallying for him to navigate this hurt while debating whether to confront her prejudice or protect his peace by stepping back.

ADVERTISEMENT

‘My (29M) friend (28F) told me she doesn’t want her child to spend time alone with me because of my stammer. I’m unsure what I should do?’

My friend just had a child 3 month go, and we're all very excited for her. I've gone to visit her, and everything was lovely. Her and her husband mentioned that they've spent pretty much 24/7 with her kid, and things were getting a bit full on. 'It would be nice to have a break' she said.

I have a background of looking after babies, have extensive medical first response training, and am altogether extremely good with children, babies, animals, people, etc. Living things just seem to like me. I offered to look after her baby free of charge if they wanted a night off to go on a date.

At this, she looks quite uncomfortable and kind of skirted around the subject - I've known her for 10 years, so I can tell when she's hiding something. I asked her if something was wrong, which she denied. I then said that if there's anything wrong, she can just tell me - we've always had a transparent and honest friendship.

ADVERTISEMENT

I was her maid of honour at her wedding. We're close enough. She then said 'Well, to be honest, I'm worried that Amy (baby) will pick up your stammer if you're with her alone for too long...' This hit me like a brick. I'm not usually speechless, but I didn't know what to say, so I just looked at her and said 'okay, if that's how you feel'..

She apologised, and I said no worries, and quickly changed the subject, and left shortly after.. I was about a hour into my drive home when I pulled over and just cried for a while. I'm not sure if there's anything to do about what happened. I don't feel like she's wrong about wanting to protect her child's development, and stammering is quite and unknown phenomenon, so I understand if she's worried if it's a learned behaviour.

But my stammer isn't even that bad. I can meet plenty of people and talk with them without stuttering - I might just get caught up on some letters and words. Is there anything to be done with this situation, or is it just one I should chalk up to life and move on? I had thoughts about spending more time with her and her child, maybe even being a cool aunt. If I have a child later on, they could be friends.... But now I don't even feel like I'm allowed to be in the same room as her.

ADVERTISEMENT

The rejection this man faced—his friend’s fear that her baby could “catch” his stammer—is not only hurtful but steeped in ableist misinformation. Stammering, a neurological speech condition, isn’t contagious or learned, as a speech therapist on Reddit affirmed. His friend’s comment, though likely not malicious, dismisses his worth and expertise, fracturing a 10-year friendship. Her discomfort, despite their closeness, suggests unchecked biases about disabilities.

This reflects a broader issue: ableism often stems from ignorance, damaging relationships. A 2023 study in the Journal of Social Issues found that misconceptions about disabilities lead to exclusion, lowering self-esteem in those targeted. His tears during the drive home signal the emotional toll of being judged for an inherent trait.

Speech-language pathologist Dr. Ellen Kelly, an expert in fluency disorders, notes, “Stammering doesn’t transfer; education can dismantle such myths.” He could address this by calmly educating his friend, perhaps writing, “I was hurt by your comment about my stammer; it’s not contagious, and I’d love to discuss this to clear up misconceptions.” This opens dialogue while asserting his dignity. If she’s defensive, distancing himself, as Redditors suggested, protects his well-being.

ADVERTISEMENT

To process the hurt, he might confide in other friends or a therapist, as past support has helped others in similar rejections. Spending time with people who value him—like other families needing his childcare skills—could rebuild confidence. If the friendship continues, setting boundaries, like avoiding solo visits, ensures respect.

Here’s how people reacted to the post:

Reddit unleashed a wave of outrage and support—here’s the community’s fiery take:

nightcat2524 − Wow. My cousin had a stutter and all I learned was how to patiently wait for him to finish his sentence. What a n**ty person. I’d focus on the friends that aren’t ashamed of me.

ADVERTISEMENT

justnotthatwitty − Amy is in zero danger of catching your stammer. She might be in danger of catching her mom’s stupidity, though.

[Reddit User] − Stammers aren't contagious. Tell Amy what she said was ableist and shameful and it's clear your friendship is over.

tn93 − Speech therapist here...'contagious' stutters are *not a thing*. That was so wrong of her to say that. Moreover, literally no one is ever 100% fluent (we all get stuck in our soeech sometimes). I am so sorry she said something that hurtful, having a stutter is challenging enough as it is. Please be assured that your stutter will never affect anyone else negatively and quite honestly should be nobody else's concern!!

ADVERTISEMENT

BelliAmie − Do you really want a 'friend' like that? Me, I'd fade out of her life.

Blue-eagle-23 − Oh my gosh, I am so sorry she was so cruel. WTF is wrong with her, that makes zero sense at all. Someone can’t “catch” a stammer and a 3 month old that your babysitting wouldn’t even notice. I certainly wouldn’t be making that long drive to visit again.

KelsarLabs − Your so called friend is a giant horses ass.. That's a walk away.

ADVERTISEMENT

sissyjones − Turning down free expert level babysitting because of a stammer. F**king stupid but her loss.

Zealousideal-Ad6358 − Hoooly s**t, what a terrible (& terribly misinformed) thing to say. That’s the last time I’d make that drive for a very, very, *very* long while, if ever. You’re a great friend & any new mom would be lucky to have you. Save that kindness for someone who actually deserves it, babe. ❤️

Unhappy_Job4447 − Just point out that you've known each other for 10yrs, and you haven't caught...... 1 Stupid. 2 arsehole. 3 you didn't even catch pregnant of her either.. Should she point out that you don't catch those things like that.. Just say she understands the point your making perfectly.

ADVERTISEMENT

These bold reactions fuel his resolve, but do they chart the next step? Reddit’s passion stirs debate, yet his path needs a steady hand.

This man’s grace in the face of his friend’s ableist rejection reveals a strength that outshines her ignorance. His story challenges us to confront biases in those we trust. Readers, have you faced judgment for a trait you can’t change? How did you respond? Share your wisdom below—let’s lift him up as he reclaims his worth!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *