How do I divorce my wife [35F] when she relies on me [35M] for everything?

ADVERTISEMENT

In a quiet suburban home, the hum of a vacuum cleaner and the clatter of grocery bags signal one man’s endless routine. For 17 years, this 35-year-old husband has been the backbone of his marriage, shouldering finances, chores, and even his wife’s social life. But beneath the surface of his devotion lies a gnawing truth: love alone can’t sustain a one-sided bond. His heart aches for a family, a partner, a life he can’t have while tethered to her dependency.

His Reddit plea spills raw emotion, painting a vivid scene of a man torn between duty and dreams. As he contemplates divorce, the weight of her fragility looms large—she leans on him for everything, from bills to friendships. Readers feel his anguish, wondering if freedom is worth her devastation. Can he break free without shattering her world, or is staying the kinder sacrifice?

ADVERTISEMENT

‘How do I divorce my wife [35F] when she relies on me [35M] for everything?’

My wife is completely dependent on me (for finances, “making life work,” friendship, etc.) and I care about her deeply, but for reasons explained below I can’t go on in this one-sided arrangement anymore. However, because I am everything to her, I know that divorcing her will be absolutely devastating, and I’m almost more comfortable killing myself than divorcing her.

(I know how ludicrous that is, and to be clear, I’m not suicidal.). To sum up what’s happening: I am moving toward divorcing my wife, S, whom I’ve been with for 17 years, since I was 18 years old. The easy way to say it is that S and I don’t have a partnership. It’s not just that she hasn’t had a job since 2013, but that she doesn’t do anything to contribute to our relationship.

I am the sole breadwinner, take care of our finances, get groceries, clean the house, etc. She doesn’t have any friends, either, because she doesn’t make the effort to make them. I actually have to introduce her to people from my life, then politely hint that she should keep in touch (“Hey, how’s Jenn doing? Maybe you should text her”).

ADVERTISEMENT

Even then, the relationships always wither. In 2017, after years of soul-searching, I asked S for a divorce. She was so devastated that I reluctantly agreed to try marriage counseling. It seemed, finally, to help: She began to apply for jobs, and was open to therapy on her own (which I arranged and drove her to, because she refuses to drive).

But once the immediate “danger” of divorce no longer hung over our marriage, she reverted to her old ways. It’s a pattern: When I ask why she won’t apply to jobs, she says she doesn’t know if she’ll like them and she’s interested in something else now. So I pay thousands of dollars for training or classes in the new thing, and after a few months she quits.

When I express my frustration, she cries and says that I make her feel like she can’t do anything right. Consciously or not, this is an extremely manipulative way to make me feel like the bad guy and to get out of taking any sort of responsibility. So even if she did get a job, it wouldn’t really change things for me, because I have 17 years of evidence to show that she won’t truly change.

ADVERTISEMENT

I just don’t trust or respect her. I don’t think she’s being malicious, but it almost doesn’t matter. We don’t have children, and I want to have children so much, but I can’t have them with her. Although this weekend she said she wants to go to grad school, she also (occasionally) says she doesn’t want to get a job because she wants to be a mom, but I cannot do that to a child.

I don’t know if S has any insight into why it’s so clear to me that she couldn’t handle motherhood. It’s painful. I love her, but I’ve given her so much support and so many chances, and I can’t have the life I want if I stay in the marriage. I hope this doesn’t sound arrogant, but I feel like I am an extraordinary husband and she isn’t grateful for anything I do.

I will probably have to pay her some sort of spousal support, perhaps indefinitely, but I am more than willing to do that if I can have a chance at the life I want. I just am so afraid of hurting her. I know, logically, that it’s not my job to live in misery to avoid hurting her feelings, and yet I’m terrified that she’ll forever be haunted by the breakdown of the only relationship she’s ever had.. How do I do this? What do I do? I’m lost and in so much pain.. Thank you for your time.

ADVERTISEMENT

NOTE: I imagine people will say S is depressed. That may be true, but she doesn’t think so. As I mentioned, I found her a therapist and would drive her to appointments, but she said she was fine and stopped going after 2-3 sessions.. ADDITION #1: To clarify, we do not have children, and are not in danger of her getting pregnant.. ADDITION #2: S has never been diagnosed with a mental disorder and has no substance abuse issues.

ADDITION #3: A few people have said that, from her behavior, S seems unintelligent. Ironically, she’s actually very bright. If you believe standardized tests, she has more “raw smarts” than I do. Which sort of makes this situation all the more frustrating. ADDITION #4: S does conceivably have a place to go if/when we split: Her parents are good people who have the room and ability to take her in, which I think would be the best way forward.

The OP’s dropped an update on the saga—curious? Click here to check it out!

ADVERTISEMENT

This man’s marriage reads like a lopsided dance—one partner spinning tirelessly, the other standing still. His wife’s dependency isn’t just practical; it’s a dynamic that stifles both their growth. His fear of hurting her is noble, but it traps him in a cycle of enabling, where her inaction becomes his burden.

Dr. John Gottman, a renowned relationship expert, states, “A healthy marriage requires both partners to contribute to mutual growth” (source). Here, the husband’s efforts—funding her classes, arranging therapy—are met with fleeting change, suggesting a deeper resistance to accountability. Her tears and deflections, intentional or not, shift blame, a tactic Gottman links to emotional manipulation.

This reflects broader issues of codependency, affecting 10-15% of couples (Psychology Today, 2021). Her lack of initiative, despite her intelligence, may hint at underlying fears or undiagnosed depression, but her refusal to engage in therapy limits solutions. Statistically, couples with one-sided dynamics face higher divorce rates (APA, 2020).

ADVERTISEMENT

He should consult a lawyer to navigate spousal support and protect his future, as indefinite alimony could prolong her dependency. Therapy for himself could clarify boundaries and ease guilt.

Here’s the feedback from the Reddit community:

Reddit’s responses are a lively mix of tough love and sharp wit, like a friend shaking you awake. From calls to lawyer up to warnings about enabling, the community doesn’t mince words. Here’s what they said:

BiggusDickus- − You are married to a b**. Divorcing her will probably be good for her because it will force her to actually start doing something productive with her life.. Ultimately you just have to do it. There is no easy way.

ADVERTISEMENT

Reverend_Vader − The most pertinent piece of info for me is where there is a sudden burst of effort when she sees her cushy number on the line. She may well be depressed but what this says to me is she is fully aware that she is both using you and her effort in the relationship is nowhere near enough. Once she feels a little comfortable/safe again, she turns off the tap as her default wish is to live off you, not with you.

You may want to bend over backwards to help her through guilt but your wife doesn't feel the same buddy, people who are comfortable using others don't often care about anyone but themselves in my experience. I think you'll find she doesn't care anywhere near as much about you once you file. If you do divorce let your lawyer set out what is fair, you're used to being used and may well agree to things you soon regret once you are out

stellastellamaris − You have to get out of this relationship. Talk to a lawyer. Find out what the steps are where you live.. If you were hit by a bus tomorrow she would cope, or she would not.. Her choices and behaviours aren't your responsibility.. Do what is right FOR YOU.

ADVERTISEMENT

PhilipTPA − My friend’s ex-wife was like this. She would go to school, finish, not work in her field, go to school some more, not work, and so on. What she DID like to do was run triathlons. She did one every two weeks and trained constantly. Basically, he worked to fund her quite amazing lifestyle.

He was a naval officer, stationed in Hawaii, and when he retired he wanted to move back to the mainland and get a private sector job (nuclear engineering). She wasn’t having any of it, insisted he stay in the Navy (not that he had a choice, up or out and there are very few Navy submarine captains). So, he moved, she stayed, he pays her a ton of alimony and she does triathlons and doesn’t work. Win win, right?

vodka_philosophy − She may be depressed, but if she won't admit it or stay in treatment there's nothing you can do about it. You've done what you can, even counseling, but nothing will work without *both* partners trying to make it work, and she isn't doing that. As for spousal support, talk to an attorney. If she's been refusing to work without your agreement, you may not have to pay it at all and at least not indefinitely.

ADVERTISEMENT

If you want to be really nice you can offer to pay spousal support for 6 months to a year to give her time to get a job. Any more than that and, honestly, you'd just be continuing to enable her to not be a responsible adult which isn't healthy for either of you. She's done a very good job of manipulating (intentionally or unintentionally) you so you feel like you can't leave her, but you can and you should for both your sakes.

throwingawaytheftr − This reminded me so much of a past relationship I had. I was working around the clock in a finance role and he couldn’t muster even applying for a single job. We broke up, got back together and broke up again. It took him 10 years to get a job. People fundamentally do NOT change unless they want to. Key emphasis on the change must come within them, not you.

The biggest shock to her system may come when you separate or leave but keep in mind you are looking for a sustained change and I think fundamentally ppl often revert to baseline. Not trying to be a Debbie downer but from someone whose lived this, do you want to continue to live this forever?

ADVERTISEMENT

LittleWinn − The hardest thing for you is really what is best for her. If you tell her you want a divorce, leave, and follow through she is forced to begin to care for herself. If you continue caring for her, you’re handicapping her. You can’t hold her hand through this, it is actually hurting her if you do.

meeheecaan − With a smile on your face thats how.

shartman126 − I just want to know what she does all day if she doesnt drive, cook, clean, anything?!?! This is clearly an unhealthy relationship. You need to cut the cord. It would be one thing if she just wasnt very social, but she just sounds lazy. Also that you went to couples therapy and nothing was resolved. If youre in charge of finances I would move out and be separated during the divorce or mediation process.

ADVERTISEMENT

[Reddit User] − I know, logically, that it’s not my job to live in misery rather than avoid hurting her feelings, and yet I’m terrified that she’ll forever be haunted by the breakdown of the only relationship she’s ever had. Even in the worst case scenario, you'd be surprised how quickly these freeloaders will pick up a job when the gravy train dries up. She's living the life of Riley so naturally she has no incentive for lasting change.

I will probably have to pay her some sort of spousal support, perhaps indefinitely, but I am more than willing to do that if I can have a chance at the life I want. I realize that it's not entirely up to you but you should try very hard to avoid a support obligation. She hasn't earned it - she's not given up anything on behalf of your career, so she doesn't deserve to benefit from it. It would be different if she'd made a career sacrifice, but she's just a layabout.

These takes are bold, but do they oversimplify her side, or is tough love the push he needs?

ADVERTISEMENT

His story is a poignant reminder that love can’t always bridge a partnership’s gaps. Caught between compassion and self-preservation, he faces a choice that could reshape both their futures. Divorcing her might spark her growth—or leave her adrift. What would you do if your dreams clashed with a loved one’s reliance? Share your experiences—how do you balance duty and personal freedom in a lopsided relationship?

For those who want to read the sequel: [UPDATE] : I [35M] followed Reddit’s advice, got divorced, & have never been happier?

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *