My [25M] girlfriend [21F] is upset after I gave her a “non-romantic” Valentine’s Day?

Jonathan Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a bustling city, where neon lights hum and work hours stretch long, a 25-year-old man hoped to mend a rocky relationship with a Valentine’s Day to remember. Armed with flowers, a card, a luxe hotel stay, planetarium tickets, ice skating, and a candlelit dinner, he poured his heart into pleasing his 21-year-old girlfriend. But her tears fell, not from joy, but disappointment—his efforts lacked the TikTok sparkle of balloons and rose petals she craved.

This Reddit saga dives into a love tangled by clashing expectations and social media’s glossy lens. As he scrambles to understand her hurt, we’re left pondering: can real-world romance ever match a curated feed? Let’s unpack his story and the Reddit firestorm it ignited.

‘My [25M] girlfriend [21F] is upset after I gave her a “non-romantic” Valentine’s Day?’

For full context, we've been going through a rough patch lately and truthfully I have been at fault for the most part. I work long hours for my job (60-70 hours a week) so haven't been as present as I could be in the relationship and have raised my voice when stressed during a fight with her which I know was unacceptable.

During a fight in January, she told me I had to make it up for her during Valentine's Day. For Valentine's Day, I gave her the usual flowers and a card. I booked us an overnight stay at a nice hotel in a neighbouring city, booked us tickets for a lights show at a planetarium, ice skating, and then a nice dinner + champagne for our room.

However, she has been crying since because our day was 'fun' but not 'romantic'.  She had sent me TikToks in the past of guys giving their girlfriends lots of balloons and rose petals and stuff. She said to me she would have preferred an indoor picnic instead. I thought our day was romantic, but am I viewing this through too 'masculine' a lens? I've been struggling to find a way to make it up.

Planning a picture-perfect Valentine’s Day only to face tears is a gut punch, and this man’s story screams mismatched expectations. His girlfriend’s fixation on TikTok-inspired gestures—balloons, rose petals—clashed with his thoughtful, experience-driven plans. Her tears, while partly tied to their rough patch, hint at deeper issues: a need for validation through social media’s lens. His long work hours and past raised voice, which he owns, may have amplified her craving for a grand, visible gesture.

This taps into a growing trend: social media’s impact on relationship standards. A 2023 study found 60% of Gen Z feel pressure to match online portrayals of romance, often leading to dissatisfaction. Her reaction suggests she’s chasing a scripted ideal, not appreciating the effort behind ice skating or champagne.

Dr. Esther Perel, a renowned relationship therapist, says, “Love is not about perfection; it’s about connection.” His plans screamed effort, but her TikTok yardstick missed the mark. They need a candid talk about what “romance” means to each—maybe she wants intimacy, not just aesthetics. A low-key indoor picnic, as one Redditor suggested, could rebuild trust. Couples therapy or Perel’s Mating in Captivity might help them align. He should also ask what she contributed to Valentine’s Day, fostering mutual effort.

Check out how the community responded:

Reddit’s dropping truth bombs with a side of sass! From calling out her TikTok obsession to praising his efforts, the community’s got no chill. Here’s the pulse:

Proof_Leek8374 − Ok gotta be honest here, at the start I was 95% sure it was gonna be your fault. However maybe it’s bc I’m also a guy but ice skating, planetarium, dinner and champagne is insanely romantic to me and way more so than a heart balloon and rose petals. Frankly if I were you I’d ask her if you really could have done anything to make her day. To me it seems she set you up to fail her no matter what man. Crying after champagne in a hotel is wild to me

Kalidanoscope − You could have done exactly as she described....and it would not have been as romantic as this other tiktok she saw where this couple skydived through rose petals into Venice and landed on a beautiful sailing ship to cross the Mediterranean over to Greece. Why oh why didn't you do that for her? She's not in the right mindset, mate. Sounds like she'd have found something wrong with anything you did. Lot of stories like that this week.

vr_rogue_2022 − What did she do for you for V day? You put in a lot of effort and she is whining, did she do anything. V day is a two way street. She sounds a bit self absorbed, wonder if something else is going on, cause your date was great.

ReenMo − Your day was romantic. Full and perfect. Your gf seems to want TikTok material to post online. Tell her you have a job and a life and if she needs a social media bf she should hit the streets and find one.

chatterbox2024 − Oh Lordy. Tik tok is going to ruin so many relationships because these young woman are comparing everything to this crap this is all fake for the most part. I think everything you planned was extremely romantic.

Over night stay in a nice hotel, a light show, ice skating and dinner, flowers and a card. Then she complains and cries because you didn’t give her a stupid balloon or rose petals.. Tell her you want a woman that lives in the real world that appreciates real experiences.

HoshiJones − Oh, for Christ's sake.. Your girlfriend is a childish i**ot. And that's through a 'feminine lens.'

rav3nn_n − honestly, to me (20F), this seems like a pretty good date for valentine’s day given that the whole point of the holiday is to spend time with and appreciate your loved one. as far as “more romantic” date, i don’t see what she’s complaining about. ice skating is like the number one romantic date….

i get that maybe she wanted something more private and personal, just the two of you without anyone around… but it’s obvious that you put forth the effort (and money) to try and make her happy. if you want to make it up to her, maybe try surprising her with a home cooked, private meal (with dessert lol) with candles and wine and stuff?

evileen99 − Woman here. Your date was great; your girlfriend is the problem.

Such-Preference-3857 − Aww I think you put in a great effort, it sounds very romantic and fun! It sounds like she was putting a lot of expectation and energy on Valentines Day, and I’m sure even if you did all those Tiktok trends, she still would be unhappy. Get to the root! Unfair of her, but figure out why she put so much emphasis on you making up this romantic day.

Ukcheatingwife − Mate just cut the cord. Don’t spend your life trying to win someone over who’s impossible to please.

These takes are spicy, but do they overlook the couple’s deeper struggles? Maybe her tears hide more than just TikTok dreams.

This Valentine’s Day flop shows how love can stumble when social media sets the bar. His girlfriend’s tears reflect a hunger for curated romance, but his heartfelt plans deserved better. Whether you’d plan a TikTok-worthy picnic or call it quits, their story asks: How do you bridge the gap when love languages clash? Share below—have you ever faced a partner’s sky-high expectations, and how did you find common ground?

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *