AITA for refusing to apologize for slapping my boyfriend when he smashed our birthday cake to my face?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

A 34-year-old woman’s dream birthday, meant to celebrate a career milestone, crumbles when her boyfriend forcibly smashes her face into a cake, cheered on by his family. Her instinctive slap in response sparks drama, with his mother claiming she’s the villain.

This Reddit post captures her humiliation and resolve to end the relationship, highlighting a clash of respect and boundaries.

‘AITA for refusing to apologize for slapping my boyfriend when he smashed our birthday cake to my face?’

My ( F34) boyfriend ( Charles M38)and I celebrate our birthdays together. This year, I contributed a small private room at a restaurant, and we invited 11 people. 4 of them are my local friends. The rest are his family members. I wanted to celebrate a new achievement in my career and thought it would be great to just splurge a little and get some delicious food.

So we had access to the menu, drinks and our cake. I had agreed to pay for ½ of the food aside from having rented the small space myself. The space was paid for in advance, the food at the end ( as in any restaurant). We had issues last year because I felt that he was doing low effort things while I always did my best to give him a nice birthday celebration.

We have an income gap, but it wasn't even about money. I was making less money last year, and I still made things work for him. So this year, he took care of inviting people, paid for the cake, and got me a spice rack as a present (which I loved). I made myself pretty, got my eyebrows and eyelashes done, and had my hair done.

We were told to pose and pretend to blow the candles ( because I didn't want to blow our germs on the cake). Then we each had a picture alone with the cake. When it was my turn, I was holding the cake when he pushed my face towards the cake, so I tried to fight it.

His family started cheering, and he arched over my body and forced me to bend over until my face smashed the cake. My friends tried to get him off me, and he resorted to plastering cake and frosting on my hair. I don't need to describe the mess because I'll never be able to end this post, but I ended up slapping him when he attempted to do it again.

His mother got up, and she got into an argument with one of my guests. I had to cross the main floor with cake all over my face to use the restroom. When I looked in the mirror, I had cake on my neck, and my blouse had red and blue coloring that didn't come off. I had to wash my face and got my hair in a bun because it looked less messy that way.

When I came back, his family were all long faces. I told him what he did was unacceptable, and he said it was just a joke, that everybody has done that for ages and that me slapping him just ruined my image in front of his family. I started crying and gathered all my stuff to leave. I notified him that he should pay for himself and his guests.

My friends insisted on paying for their own food, but I refused, and we ended the night right there. My friends wanted to treat me to having dinner elsewhere, but I wasn't comfortable with my appearance. They ended up sending me the money that I spent, and that broke my heart.

Charles had to pay for ½ of the remaining bill and got charged a cleaning fee. I still love him, but I'm clear that I'll never be able to forgive him. We talked about it, and I ended things. He's convinced that I never loved him. He acknowledged what he did was wrong but is adamant that his family hates me for slapping him and that it's my fault.

I told him that he ruined not only our birthday but also my way to celebrate my career milestone. I've worked very hard to get to where I am and that his behavior showed me what my future will look like.

And that I'm sorry to say it, but he was so aggressive and so focused on making his family laugh at my expense that I just realized he's not good enough and that I've lost my confidence to be seen with him in public, because I don't know what else he will pull out of his ass.

He says he paid for that cake, that he's not saying that it was okay to smash it, but it's not like I paid for everything. He wanted me to apologize to his mom, but I refused. Important: I'm not proud of my reaction. We've never had any physical altercations.

He says his mother feels humiliated because of what I did and that she has been struggling with mild depression for years ( I didn't know), and I came off as violent.. AITA for refusing? I already blocked him. Edit: his guests paid for the other half of his bill after being told they needed not pay for anything.

A birthday celebration meant to honor a career milestone became a public humiliation when this woman’s boyfriend forcibly pushed her face into a cake, ignoring her resistance. His dismissal of her reaction and demand for an apology to his mother reveal a deeper lack of respect. Her slap, while regrettable, stemmed from a moment of self-defense against his aggressive act.

Psychologist Dr. Harriet Lerner explains, “Respect in relationships requires honoring boundaries, especially in public settings. Humiliating acts, even framed as jokes, can fracture trust”. The boyfriend’s physical overreach, cheered by his family, disregarded her consent, while his refusal to fully own the harm deepened the rift. Her decision to end the relationship reflects a stand for self-worth.

This incident mirrors broader issues of respect in partnerships. A 2022 study in the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships found that 48% of women report experiencing public humiliation by partners, often tied to power dynamics. The boyfriend’s focus on his family’s approval over her feelings suggests unhealthy priorities.

For healing, the woman should prioritize self-care and seek therapy to process the humiliation and physical response. If reconciliation were considered, the boyfriend would need to demonstrate accountability through counseling and clear respect for boundaries. Her resolve to walk away, however, signals strength in prioritizing dignity over a toxic dynamic.

These are the responses from Reddit users:

The Reddit community rallied behind the woman, condemning her boyfriend’s cake-smashing as disrespectful and aggressive, with many labeling it assault for ignoring her clear resistance. Commenters dismissed his family’s outrage, arguing that his mother’s humiliation paled compared to the public shaming the woman endured.

Some praised her for ending the relationship, seeing his actions and lack of remorse as red flags for future disrespect. These reactions underscore a consensus that her slap was a defensive response to a humiliating violation.

StatusDiamond339 − NTA. The reason being is that you physically resisted having your face forced into a cake. He did it anyways, and attempted to do it a second time. I don’t blame you for the slap in this situation — he tried to force you AGAIN when you clearly didn’t want to.

If someone were trying to force my face into a cake I was holding, I woulda dropped it right on the floor and walked out the door. I’d be done with that relationship. It wasn’t a “joke”, no means no.. He and his family sound like a whole entourage of assholes.

No-Raise-6786 − Wait, she thinks YOU came off as violent after watching him struggle to force your face into the cake?. You did right. He sounds abusive and lazy, throw him and the whole i**ot family away.

Fun_Ideal_5584 − His mother feels humiliated. You came off VIOLENT? Did she not see what he did to you?' When it was my turn, I was holding the cake when he pushed my face towards the cake, so I tried to fight it.

His family started cheering, and he arched over my body and forced me to bend over until my face smashed the cake. My friends tried to get him off me, and he resorted to plastering cake and frosting on my hair'.. How does one do this to their future spouse, then act like it was nothing but fun times?

chaingun_samurai − me slapping him just ruined my image in front of his family.. 'Do you think *I F**KING CARE*!?'.

Special_Slide_2257 − The only apology I’d give the witch who whelped him is “I’m sorry you raised a man capable of assaulting the woman he supposedly loves in order to get a few cheap laughs.” What he did was a**ault, what you did was more self defense (he was trying to repeat the a**ault). NTA

VeggiesForLyfe − Shoving someone into a cake without their consent is a**ault and I will die on that hill.. You acted in self-defense.. His mother should be humiliated because she raised a man that assaults the people he cares about.. NTA and please never speak to any of these people ever again.

Fancy-Escape8788 − NTA. This wasn’t a joke, it was just mean. You struggled against him, so he knew that you didn’t want him to do this. He ruined your night, your makeup, hair and clothing. He humiliated you in front of his family, your friends and everyone in the restaurant.

The worst thing is that he actually planned doing this to you. You slapped him in the heat of the moment. I don’t think that you owe him or his mother an apology. She should have been angry with her son for humiliating his girlfriend.

SageBreezet − He took a moment that was supposed to be about your celebration and made it all about his childish antics, humiliating you in front of everyone his refusal to apologize only proves he doesn't respect you.

hdgal63 − NTA, honestly you answered his violence with a natural reaction. He was violent to you by refusing to allow you to say no. he physically had to use his body to push your face into that cake. That was humiliating to you, downgrading to you and showed zero consideration to you. You are well rid of him and his family owes you the apology, not the other way around.

myfalteredego − You have a typo. You listed him as 38 years old, I think you meant 18.

This birthday disaster exposes the fragility of trust when respect is trampled. The woman’s decision to end her relationship after her boyfriend’s humiliating act and refusal to fully own it reflects a powerful stand for self-respect.

While her slap wasn’t ideal, it stemmed from a moment of violation. Have you faced a public moment that tested your boundaries in a relationship? Share your stories—let’s keep the conversation going!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *