AITA for breaking up with my girlfriend after she told me she can’t get over how much she hates my body?

Shirley Stafford Hours
Comments 0 Comments

In a cozy coffee shop, where the aroma of espresso mingles with whispered secrets, a young man’s world quietly shatters. At just 29, he thought he’d found his forever love—until his girlfriend’s confession sliced through his confidence like a cold wind. Her words weren’t about betrayal or lies but something far more personal: his height. At 5’2″, he’d long buried the sting of high school taunts, yet here it was, resurfacing in the one place he felt safe.

The revelation left him reeling, his heart caught between love and self-worth. How do you stay with someone who’s trying to “fix” their feelings about a part of you that’s unchangeable? Readers, brace yourselves for a story that tugs at the heartstrings, sparking questions about acceptance, love, and the courage to walk away when respect falters.

‘AITA for breaking up with my girlfriend after she told me she can’t get over how much she hates my body?’

I (29M) had been dating my girlfriend Kara (27F) for about a year. She’d always tell me I was exactly what she wanted in a partner—funny, kind, supportive. It felt like we were really happy together, and I thought I’d finally found someone who loved me for who I was.

But last week, Kara told me she needed to talk. She looked so serious that I thought she was about to bring up something big. She took a deep breath and told me, “I’ve been talking to my therapist, and I need to be honest with you about something I’m struggling with.”

I thought this would be something about her past, like a trauma she's working through, so I told her that she could talk to me about anything. Then she said, “I’ve tried so hard to accept it, but… I just can’t get over your height.” I’m 5'2”, and she’s 5'8”, so there’s a noticeable difference, but I honestly thought it didn't mean much.

But now, she was saying it was this huge problem for her, one that she’d been “working on” in therapy. She told me it was literally “the only thing that wasn’t perfect” about me. I sat there, kind of stunned. When I was younger, I my height was my biggest insecurity.

I was severely bullied and mocked for it in highschool, and even after I was an adult, I still was ridiculed for it to the point where I considered surgery. I don't really feel that bad about it now, but her saying this really brought all of those feelings back.

The idea that someone I loved so much tried to

She started crying, saying she didn’t mean to hurt me and really did love me—just, you know, minus this one part of me I couldn’t change. She was saying that she'd work on it in therapy and try to not care, but I left that night, and we haven’t talked since.

When I told a couple of my friends, they actually took her side. They said I was being insecure, that I should’ve just “worked on it” with her. One even said, “She’s just being honest, man.”. So, was an insecure a**hole?

Relationships thrive on acceptance, but this story shows what happens when it falters. The boyfriend, haunted by past bullying, was devastated when his girlfriend admitted she couldn’t accept his 5’2″ height, despite therapy. Her honesty aimed to bridge a gap but reopened his wounds. He chose self-respect, ending things, while she wrestled with her bias.

Her openness clashed with his need for unconditional love, highlighting a disconnect. She saw therapy as progress; he saw rejection. A 2021 Journal of Social Psychology study notes 60% of adults face body-based discrimination, often over traits like height (Journal of Social Psychology).

Dr. John Gottman, a relationship expert, says, “Acceptance is the foundation of intimacy” (Gottman Institute). Her struggle eroded trust, pushing him to prioritize self-worth. Couples facing such issues could try joint counseling to build empathy. He might heal by finding partners who fully embrace him.

These are the responses from Reddit users:

Reddit’s crew dove into this height-fueled breakup with gusto, serving up a spicy mix of cheers and jeers. Picture a lively bar where everyone’s got an opinion, and the drinks are flowing as freely as the shade. Here’s the unfiltered scoop from the online crowd, packed with fist-bumps for the boyfriend and eye-rolls for his ex’s hang-up.

EggplantIll4927 − D**p her ass. Today. That’s like telling her your boobs are wrong. Or worse! It is not ok. And what exactly does she want you to do about it? Nope. Put her out w the trash. You are perfect just as you are. This is so n**ty of her. 😡. eta I am a woman

evil_overlord01 − What's the profit in sharing this with you in the first place? It's not like it's something that you can change, and it's her hang up. If she needed to work on it, she should have kept that to herself.

n7shepard1987 − YNW, specially cos I'm guessing she knows about your insecurities and bullying in the past. She needs to work on herself, not her shallow views. I'll never understand how a partner's height can matter so much to some people, you're sat down- you're just about the same height weather you're 4 foot six or 6 6.

Laying down, again what's it matter, enjoying a hobby together(unless you're hobby is the high jump it's probs not gonna make a difference. I know it's easier said than done but try and put what she said to the back of your mind and keep going ahead with movimg on,

I've had a comment about something I couldn't change from an ex that made everything different and couldn't continue in the relationship because of it. Sometimes you're just better off starting again. (I usually hate the Reddit culture of speedrunnin to breaking up but sometimes one comment is too much to get past)

Asleep_Cash_8199 − Absolutely NTA. This isn't a minor part of your identity. It is also something that is incredible hard to adjust (bone extension surgery). You are right to feel hurt. If it was your haircut, your choice of clothes, then you could have changed. But your height is who you are.. If it was a problem for her, she shouldn't have dated you in the first place.. Don't let your

One_Last_Cry − It's an odd hang-up for height (something you can't easily alter) to be a point of contention in a relationship. I don't believe there would be any amount of

How has she been able to deal with it for this long of a duration if it bothers her so? This is a character flaw that she would have to work on and overcome (if possible) for you two to even begin to heal. And then there's your trauma surrounding the subject

Do you really believe that you could continue a relationship with her, knowing she feels as she does? I'm sorry to have this happen to you and hope you two can somehow reconcile this situation by whatever means you find necessary.

Salt-Environment9285 − you cannot fix height.. or stupid. and she definitely is.. wait until she finds a tall man who treats her like garbage.

SeedSowHopeGrow − She will regret her decision

AlwaysGreen2 − No, you are not.. But your friends are jerks.. Find some new friends and a new girlfriend.. Break up with the girlfriend and distance yourself from these so-called friends.. You sound like a great guy.. Take some time to mourn this situation and then move on..

Broaden your circle.. Get out here.. Stay strong and positive.. Thank God that you dodged a bullet.. You will find the perfect person for you one day.. The best is yet to come for you, my friend.. I wish you well.

[Reddit User] − This is exactly as others have noted like telling her her boobs are too small but you’ll try and do your best to deal. If that was the story we equally tell that person to d**p the person saying that. Do me a favor OP; go and find someone great who loves you and doesn’t care about your height and be incredibly happy. That’s the best revenge; a life well lived.

rocketmn69_ − Yep. NTA. She doesn't have e to worry about it anymore. You need to d**p your friends too. If therapy after a year hasn't helped her, then nothing will. She never said she wanted to be with you, just that she couldn't deal with your height.. She hasn't tried to call you since...there's your answer. You did the right thing. Onwards and upwards to new people.

These Redditors came out swinging, with most rallying behind the boyfriend’s choice to walk away, praising his stand for self-respect. Others tossed some light shade at the girlfriend’s therapy-fueled confession, questioning why she aired a bias she couldn’t change. A few even called out the friends for missing the mark. But are these keyboard crusaders catching the full story, or just fanning the flames of drama? One thing’s certain—this tale of love and limits has the internet buzzing.

This tale of love, height, and hard choices reminds us that relationships thrive on mutual respect—not just effort. The boyfriend’s decision to walk away wasn’t just about height; it was about reclaiming his dignity. His girlfriend’s honesty, though brave, missed the mark, leaving both to grapple with their truths. What would you do if a partner couldn’t accept a part of you? Share your thoughts, stories, or hot takes below—let’s keep this convo rolling!

Share this post

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *