AITA for not giving my sister my baby?

A family gathering took a shocking turn when a pregnant woman’s half-sister demanded her unborn child, claiming she deserved it more. Backed by her father and stepmother, the sister’s entitlement escalated into a disturbing confrontation, leaving the woman and her husband reeling.

This isn’t just about a family feud; it’s a chilling tale of jealousy and delusion. The story thrusts us into a surreal family dynamic, raising questions about safety and boundaries in the face of obsession.

‘AITA for not giving my sister my baby?’

A half-sister’s demand for a pregnant woman’s baby isn’t just outrageous—it’s a red flag for deeper psychological issues. Lia’s jealousy, fueled by her failed engagement and unfulfilled desire for a child, exploded into a delusional claim, supported by her parents’ enabling.

Her touchy behavior with the woman’s husband and fixation on the pregnancy suggest an unhealthy obsession, potentially dangerous given her emotional volatility. The woman’s immune-compromised state adds urgency to protecting her health and safety.

Entitlement in families can escalate to harm: a 2022 Journal of Family Violence study found 20% of family disputes involving jealousy lead to threats or aggression when unchecked. Lia’s outburst and physical clinginess to Lucas signal boundary violations that could worsen post-birth. Psychologist Dr. Ramani Durvasula warns, “Unaddressed envy in families can spiral into destructive behavior, requiring firm boundaries or distance” (.

The woman should go no-contact with Lia, her father, and stepmother, documenting all interactions and considering a restraining order, especially citing cases like Taylor Parker’s. Security cameras and a move—possibly to Sweden—could ensure safety. Therapy can help her process this trauma, while her mother’s support offers a lifeline. Her husband’s swift action shows strength, but they must stay vigilant.

These are the responses from Reddit users:

Reddit was unanimous in declaring the woman NTA, labeling Lia’s demand as psychotic and dangerous, with her parents’ support equally alarming. They urged cutting contact entirely, installing security cameras, and pursuing restraining orders, warning that Lia’s obsession could escalate to kidnapping or harm, especially post-birth.

Many recommended moving far away, possibly to Sweden, and praised the husband’s quick eviction of the trio. The consensus was clear: protect the baby and family at all costs from this unhinged behavior.

This wasn’t just a family argument—it was a wake-up call about obsession and danger. Lia’s demand for a baby, backed by enablers, exposed a threat the woman can’t ignore. As she safeguards her growing family, it’s a reminder that love doesn’t justify delusion. How do you handle toxic family demands? Share your story—what’s your strategy for staying safe?